Potbelly Menu with Prices, Calories and Popular Items
Are you craving a warm, toasted sandwich, a comforting bowl of soup, or a legendary hand-dipped milkshake? Potbelly Sandwich Works (commonly known as just Potbelly) is a favorite fast-casual destination famous for its cozy antique decor, live acoustic music, and perfectly toasted subs topped with iconic Chicago-style hot peppers.
This comprehensive guide to the Potbelly menu provides everything you need to know before your next visit or online order. We cover updated menu prices, calories, and customized sizes (Skinny, Original, and BIG). You will also find an insider look at the famous "Underground Menu," critical allergen and dietary options (including gluten-free and vegan workarounds), and actionable value hacks to help you save money.
Disclaimer: Prices, item availability, and ingredient selections vary significantly by geographic location, franchise policies, and whether you order in-shop or through third-party delivery apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats.
Menu Snapshot: Quick Answer
Potbelly is famous for its toasted sandwiches, customized milkshakes, and fresh-baked cookies. Sandwiches are priced by size: Skinny (approx. $6.80–$7.80), Original (approx. $8.30–$9.50), and BIG (approx. $10.50–$11.90). To find exact prices for your nearest location, use the official app or visit the restaurant's website.
Official Source Verification
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can vary by location, delivery platform, and time. LatestMenus checks official restaurant sources where available and marks uncertain information clearly.
Understanding Potbelly Sandwich Sizes
Before checking the menu prices, it is crucial to understand Potbelly’s three main sandwich sizes:
- Skinny: A lighter 6-inch portion served on thin-cut bread with less meat and cheese (typically saves 30% of the calories).
- Original: The classic 7.5-inch size and standard recipe.
- BIG: A massive 10.5-inch roll packaged with 30% more ingredients than the Original size.
- Custom Bread Options: Choose White or Whole Wheat. You can also request it Flat (flatbread) or Skinny Cut (staff scoop out the soft interior breading to lower carbs and calories).
Latest Potbelly Menu Prices
Below are sample prices and official calories for popular menu items. Prices vary by location and are estimates based on standard metropolitan pricing. For context, if you love to explore different toasted sub styles, you might also compare this with the Lubi's Hot Subs menu.
Toasted Sandwiches
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-Wreck® | Sandwich | $8.89 (Original) / Varies | 680 (Original) | Meat lovers | Skinny: ~$7.29 (400 Cal) | BIG: ~$11.19 (1040 Cal). Roast beef, turkey, ham, salami, Swiss. |
| Italian | Sandwich | $9.09 (Original) / Varies | 780 (Original) | Classic deli fans | Skinny: ~$7.49 (470 Cal) | BIG: ~$11.39 (1170 Cal). Capicola, mortadella, pepperoni, salami, provolone. |
| Turkey Breast | Sandwich | $8.39 (Original) / Varies | 510 (Original) | Lighter appetites | Skinny: ~$6.99 (290 Cal) | BIG: ~$10.69 (770 Cal). Sliced turkey and Swiss cheese. |
| Grilled Chicken | Sandwich | $8.89 (Original) / Varies | 540 (Original) | High protein focus | Skinny: ~$7.29 (310 Cal) | BIG: ~$11.19 (820 Cal). Grilled chicken breast, melted provolone. |
| Mediterranean | Sandwich | $8.39 (Original) / Varies | 590 (Original) | Vegetarians (if ordered without chicken) | Skinny: ~$6.99 (350 Cal) | BIG: ~$10.69 (910 Cal). Zesty chicken, hummus, feta, artichokes, red peppers. |
| Pizza Sandwich | Sandwich | $7.99 (Original) / Varies | 790 (Original) | Comfort food cravings | BIG: ~$10.29 (1190 Cal). Pepperoni, meatball, capicola, marinara, provolone. |
| Powerhouse Vegetarian | Sandwich | $7.99 (Original) / Varies | 690 (Original) | Vegetarians | Skinny: ~$6.79 (370 Cal) | BIG: ~$10.29 (1030 Cal). Hummus, avocado, provolone, cheddar, Swiss, veggies. |
| PB & J | Sandwich | $4.99 (Original) / Varies | 710 (Original) | Kids & sweet tooths | Peanut butter & jelly served warm. Not available in Skinny or BIG sizes. |
Fresh Salads, Soups, and Mac
Salads typically come with a sourdough bread roll (120 calories) and choice of dressing.
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Farmhouse Salad | Salad | $10.49 / Varies | 430 (Base) | A hearty lunch | Chicken, bacon, hard-boiled egg, blue cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers. |
| Uptown Salad | Salad | $10.49 / Varies | 370 (Base) | Sweet & savory mix | Chicken, grapes, apples, cranberries, candied walnuts, blue cheese. |
| Chicken Potpie Soup | Soup | $4.99 Cup / $6.49 Bowl | 260 Cup / 390 Bowl | Cold days | Creamy chicken filling topped with a crispy puff pastry lid. |
| Broccoli Cheddar Soup | Soup | $4.99 Cup / $6.49 Bowl | 200 Cup / 310 Bowl | Cheese lovers | Rich velvety broth with tender broccoli florets. |
| Mac & Cheese | Mac | $5.29 Cup / $6.89 Bowl | 360 Cup / 550 Bowl | A filling side | Creamy three-cheese sauce over tender spiral pasta. |
Shakes, Sweets & Sides
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hand-Spun Milkshake | Dessert | $5.29 / Varies | 550 - 780 | Dipping your sandwich | Oreo, Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Banana. Includes signature cookie on the straw. |
| Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie | Dessert | $2.19 / Varies | 410 | A classic treat | Baked fresh in-store daily. Highly popular. |
| Zapp's Potato Chips | Side | $1.99 / Varies | 140 - 220 | Added crunch | Voodoo, Kettle, Salt & Vinegar, Mesquite BBQ. |
| Whole Deli Pickle | Side | $1.49 / Varies | 15 | Low calorie add-on | Crisp, sour kosher dill pickle. |
Popular Menu Items
If it is your first time checking out the Potbelly menu, these signature items are what built the restaurant's reputation nationwide:
| Popular Item | Why People Order It | Price Note | Calorie Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| The A-Wreck® Sandwich | The ultimate meat-lover's sub packed with roast beef, turkey, ham, salami, and Swiss. | Usually the most expensive base sandwich. | 680 Calories (Original) |
| Chicken Potpie Soup | Incredibly thick, comforting soup uniquely topped with a real puff pastry lid. | Great value when ordered as a "Pick Your Pair". | 390 Calories (Bowl) |
| Oreo® Hand-Spun Shake | Thick, rich, and features Potbelly's signature touch-a mini butter cookie on the straw. | Premium dessert pricing. | 780 Calories |
| Hot Peppers (Giardiniera) | An authentic Chicago-style topping that adds massive flavor and crunch. | Free to add to sandwiches; full jars cost extra. | Minimal (mostly oil/veggies). |
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
These are LatestMenus editorial recommendations based on available menu research, value, popularity, customization potential, and practical ordering usefulness. They are not official restaurant rankings.
The A-Wreck® Sandwich
Combining four different meats and Swiss cheese, this signature toasted sandwich is the perfect representation of Potbelly's deli roots.
"Pick Your Pair" Combo
Choosing a half-sandwich (Skinny size) alongside a cup of soup or Mac & Cheese gives you variety while saving roughly $1.50 over buying items separately.
The BIG Sharing Hack
Ordering a 10.5-inch BIG sandwich and splitting it provides nearly the same amount of food as two Skinny sandwiches for significantly less money.
Turkey Breast on "Skinny Cut"
By requesting the bread "Skinny Cut" (scooped out) and using mustard instead of mayo, you can enjoy an Original-sized sandwich with significantly fewer carbs and calories.
The Lucky 7 (Underground Menu)
This off-menu item upgrades the classic A-Wreck by adding bacon and provolone, resulting in a towering sandwich with seven meats and cheeses.
Cheapest Items and Best Value Picks
If you are looking to stretch your dollar at Potbelly, the menu offers a few strategic ways to order. Fans of hearty soup and half-sandwich combos might also find good value comparisons on the Newk's Eatery menu.
| Value Pick | Why It Can Be Good Value | Watch Out For | Best Ordering Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pick Your Pair | Combines a Skinny sandwich with soup, mac, or half-salad, saving $1.50-$2.00 vs buying separately. | Premium soups or salads may add an upcharge. | Pair a Skinny Turkey with Chicken Potpie Soup for maximum comfort at a lower price. |
| Potbelly Perks (App) | Earn points ("Smiles") on every purchase for free food. | Points expire if your account is inactive for too long. | New users typically get a free sandwich or cookie offer upon signing up. |
| The BIG Size Hack | BIG sandwiches offer 30% more meat and cheese and a larger roll at a lower cost-per-ounce. | It is a very high-calorie option if you eat it alone. | Order one BIG sandwich, ask them to cut it in half, and share it with a dining partner. |
The Potbelly Underground Menu (Secret Menu)
Potbelly has an officially acknowledged "Underground Menu" featuring popular customizations that aren't on the standard overhead boards. You can order these in-shop by name or build them through the app:
- The Lucky 7: An "A-Wreck" plus bacon and provolone (seven total meats/cheeses).
- The Wrecking Ball: The classic "A-Wreck" mixed with the Meatball sandwich ingredients.
- The Fireball: A spicy meatball sandwich loaded with extra hot giardiniera peppers and provolone.
- The Gladiator: A toasted flatbread crust layered with bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo.
Calories and Nutrition Notes
Potbelly makes it relatively easy to monitor your nutrition. Full details are available via their official website's nutrition calculator.
| Menu Area | Nutrition Note | Best For | Source Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sandwich Sizes | Skinny portions generally save 25%-35% of the calories compared to Original sizes. | Calorie restriction without sacrificing flavor. | High |
| "Skinny Cut" Bread | Asking staff to hollow out your bread saves roughly 80-120 calories on an Original roll. | Reducing carbohydrate intake. | High |
| Condiments | Standard mayo adds 90-150 calories. Mustard or vinegar add almost zero. | Lowering fat content. | High |
Allergen and Dietary Notes
Potbelly publishes a thorough dietary guide, but diners with severe allergies should note that cross-contact is always a risk in their open-air kitchen setup.
| Dietary Need | What to Check | Important Note |
|---|---|---|
| Gluten-Free | Potbelly does NOT offer gluten-free sandwich bread. | You can order any sandwich "as a salad" (removing the bread) or order soups/salads without the side roll. |
| Vegetarian | Powerhouse Vegetarian, Mac & Cheese, and PB&J are completely meat-free. | You can also request the Mediterranean sandwich or Uptown Salad without chicken. |
| Vegan | The sourdough bread roll and Garden Vegetable Soup are vegan. | Order the Powerhouse or Mediterranean without meat/cheese, add avocado, and use oil/vinegar. |
Best For: Who This Menu Guide Helps
This Potbelly menu guide is designed to help:
- First-time visitors who need to understand the Skinny, Original, and BIG sizing system.
- Value-focused diners looking for the best combos and sharing hacks.
- Health-conscious eaters who want official calorie counts and ordering tricks like "Skinny Cut" bread.
- Secret menu fans looking for the best Potbelly Underground Menu creations.
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
Use these practical tips to ensure you get exactly what you want while managing your budget and dietary needs.
- Check the official app or local restaurant for exact prices. Menu prices vary by city, franchise ownership, and state regulations.
- Watch for delivery markups. Third-party delivery prices on Uber Eats or DoorDash are frequently marked up higher than in-store pick-up prices.
- Ask for "Skinny Cut" to save carbs. If you want less bread without shrinking your meat/cheese portion to the "Skinny" size, this is the best customization hack.
- Buy hot peppers by the jar. If you love the famous Chicago-style hot peppers, you can purchase a full retail jar right at the register to take home.
- Use official nutrition and allergen pages before ordering. Potbelly's official website has a robust calculator to test customizations in real-time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the three sandwich sizes at Potbelly?
Potbelly offers three sizes: Skinny (6 inches on thin-cut bread with a lighter portion of meat/cheese), Original (7.5 inches, standard recipe), and BIG (10.5 inches with 30% more meat and cheese than the Original).
Does Potbelly have a menu with prices?
Yes, but Potbelly does not publish a universal national price list. Because prices vary by local market, the best way to see exact pricing is to enter your zip code into the official Potbelly app or website.
Where can I find Potbelly calories?
Potbelly lists calories next to all menu items on their in-store overhead boards and digital app menus. They also provide a full nutrition calculator on their official website.
Does Potbelly have gluten-free bread?
No, Potbelly does not offer gluten-free bread. If you are avoiding gluten, your best option is to order a salad or request a "sandwich in a bowl" (your sandwich toppings served over a bed of romaine lettuce).
What is on the Potbelly Underground Menu?
The Underground Menu consists of unlisted fan-favorite combinations. The most popular are the Lucky 7 (A-Wreck with bacon and provolone), Wrecking Ball (A-Wreck plus meatballs), and the Fireball (spicy meatballs with hot peppers).
What are the best things to order at Potbelly?
The most popular choices are the meat-packed A-Wreck® sandwich, the creamy Chicken Potpie Soup, and the freshly baked Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie.
Are the hot peppers at Potbelly free?
Yes, you can add Potbelly's signature hot giardiniera peppers to any sandwich, salad, or soup at no extra charge.
Are delivery prices different than in-store prices?
Yes, prices listed on third-party delivery apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats are typically marked up by 15% to 30% to cover service fees. Ordering pick-up directly through the Potbelly app is usually cheaper.
Conclusion
Whether you prefer the massive, meat-heavy A-Wreck on a BIG roll or a light Skinny Turkey Breast sandwich with a side of soup, the Potbelly menu offers something for every appetite. Remember to utilize the Potbelly Perks app for rewards, check out the Underground Menu for fun customizations, and use the "Skinny Cut" bread hack to manage your calories.
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can change by location, time, delivery platform, and restaurant updates. Always confirm the latest information with the official restaurant website, app, or your local restaurant before ordering. Information verified for 2026 where available.
