Goodfellas Pizza Menu with Prices, Calories and Popular Items
Goodfellas Pizzeria has built a massive reputation by serving authentic Brooklyn-style "Big Slices" from their legendary 22-inch jumbo pies. Famous for its Prohibition-era aesthetic, the attached Wiseguy Lounge, and incredibly large portion sizes, this pizzeria brings a true slice of New York to the Midwest and the South. Whether you are grabbing a quick late-night snack, looking for an affordable lunch combo, or ordering giant pies for a weekend gathering, understanding the Goodfellas Pizza menu can help you navigate their specialty combinations and massive sizing.
This comprehensive 2026 guide covers the latest Goodfellas Pizza menu, including updated price estimates, estimated calorie counts, and the best value picks like their iconic lunch special. We also provide essential information on allergens, nutrition, and tips for ordering through their app or in-store.
Disclaimer: Prices and item availability vary significantly by location (e.g., Lexington, Cincinnati, Indianapolis) and delivery platform. Always check your local Goodfellas Pizzeria or their official online ordering portal for the most accurate data.
Menu Snapshot: Quick Answer
Goodfellas Pizzeria specializes in 22-inch New York-style pizzas, sold both whole and by the massive slice. While official calories are not published, a single giant cheese slice typically ranges from $4.50 to $6.00 depending on location, providing a substantial meal at an accessible price point.
Official Source Verification
Official Source Verification
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can vary by location, delivery platform, and time. LatestMenus checks official restaurant sources where available and marks uncertain information clearly.
Latest Goodfellas Pizza Menu Prices
Goodfellas operates on a model that allows customers to order whole pies (in 12-inch or 22-inch sizes) or walk up to the counter for a giant slice. Because they don't have a nationwide pricing structure, the prices listed below are estimations based on in-store averages. Delivery app prices will generally be 15-20% higher.
If you are a fan of evaluating traditional Italian-style menus, checking out the Original Italian Pizza Berwick menu offers another interesting look at authentic pie styles.
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese Slice | Pizza by the Slice | Est. $4.50 - $5.50 | Est. 550 - 650 | Quick lunches, late-night snacking | A massive 1/6th of a 22" giant pie. |
| Pepperoni Slice | Pizza by the Slice | Est. $5.50 - $6.50 | Est. 650 - 750 | Classic NY pizza fans | The staple choice at any NY-style pizzeria. |
| Specialty Slice | Pizza by the Slice | Est. $6.50 - $7.50 | Est. 700 - 850 | Variety seekers | Rotates daily based on location. Check the chalkboard. |
| 12" Cheese Pizza | Whole Pies | Est. $14.00 - $16.00 | Est. 1,200 total | Solo dinners or 2 people sharing | Cut into 6 smaller slices. Gluten-free often available in this size. |
| 22" Jumbo Cheese | Whole Pies | Est. $28.00 - $32.00 | Est. 3,300 - 3,900 | Parties, events, family dinners | The famous 8-slice party size pie. |
| The Wiseguy (22") | Specialty Pies | Est. $34.00 - $38.00 | Check official sources | Vegetarians and garlic lovers | Topped with garlic, spinach, mushrooms, and red onion. |
| The Don (22") | Specialty Pies | Est. $36.00 - $40.00 | Check official sources | Heavy meat eaters | All-meat: Pepperoni, sausage, beef, bacon, ham. |
| The Boss (22") | Specialty Pies | Est. $36.00 - $40.00 | Check official sources | Supreme pizza fans | Meat and vegetable mix, similar to a traditional deluxe. |
| Breadsticks (Order of 2) | Sides | Est. $6.00 - $8.00 | Est. 400 - 600 | Appetizers or sharing | Giant hand-rolled sticks. Includes a dipping sauce. |
| Side Salad | Salads | Est. $5.00 - $7.00 | Est. 150 - 300 | Adding greens to a heavy meal | Usually available in Garden or Caesar. |
| Cannoli | Desserts | Est. $4.50 - $6.00 | Est. 350 | Italian dessert fans | Authentic ricotta and chocolate chip filling. |
Popular Menu Items
When evaluating different pizzerias, seeing what the locals order is often the best strategy. If you want to compare specialty pizzas across different establishments, looking at the Italy's Best Pizza menu provides a great baseline. At Goodfellas, the focus is all about size, bold flavor profiles, and authentic New York textures.
| Popular Item | Why People Order It | Price Note | Calorie Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Wiseguy Pizza | The earthy combination of roasted garlic, mushrooms, spinach, and red onion makes it their most popular vegetarian option. | Premium specialty pricing | Not published |
| The Don | A massive, heavy meat-lovers pie loaded with five different types of meat. Perfect for sharing with hungry groups. | Highest price tier | High density |
| Jumbo Breadsticks | These aren't your typical pizza chain sticks. They are massive, soft, hand-rolled, and served with house-made dips like spicy ranch. | Excellent side value | High carbohydrate |
| The Lunch Special | It combines a giant slice, a side (like the breadstick), and a drink into one perfectly priced package. | Best overall deal | Complete meal |
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
These are LatestMenus editorial recommendations based on available menu research, value, popularity, customization potential, and practical ordering usefulness. They are not official restaurant rankings.
The Lunch Special
This is the most authentic way to experience Goodfellas. You get a massive slice of pizza, a forearm-sized breadstick (or salad), and a drink, usually all for around $10-$12 depending on your location.
Cheese Slice
A single cheese slice here is 1/6th of a 22-inch pie. For roughly $5.00, it delivers more food volume than most fast-food burgers.
22" Build-Your-Own Pie
Ordering a 22-inch pie gives you eight gigantic slices. It's an interactive, fun way to feed a family of 4-5 without ordering multiple smaller pizzas.
12" Wiseguy Pizza (Thin Crust)
If you skip the jumbo pies, the 12-inch Wiseguy offers a vegetarian profile packed with spinach and mushrooms, making it slightly less heavy than the meat options.
Jumbo Breadsticks with Garlic Butter
The breadsticks are iconic. The dough is baked fresh and paired with their signature garlic butter or marinara dipping sauce.
Classic Cannoli
Instead of cookies or brownies, Goodfellas sticks to its Italian roots with a classic cannoli filled with sweet ricotta.
Cheapest Items and Best Value Picks
Pizzerias that sell by the slice naturally offer great ways to save money if you order strategically.
| Value Pick | Why It Can Be Good Value | Watch Out For | Best Ordering Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Lunch Combo | Combines a slice, a side, and a drink for less than the cost of buying them individually. | Usually only available until 3:00 PM or 4:00 PM (varies by store). | Choose the breadstick as your side for the most food volume. |
| Basic Slices | One $5 slice is often enough to fill up an average diner due to the 22-inch pie scaling. | Specialty slices can cost $2-$3 more than plain cheese. | Stick to cheese or standard pepperoni to keep the check low. |
| 12" Pies for Two | If you only have two people, a 12-inch pie is cheaper than a 22-inch and prevents over-ordering. | The per-square-inch price is technically worse than the jumbo pie. | Split a 12-inch and add a side salad to stretch the meal. |
Calories and Nutrition Notes
Unlike massive global fast-food chains, Goodfellas Pizzeria operates as a craft regional chain and does not publish an official calorie matrix or nutritional guide online. If you are strictly counting calories, this makes eating here slightly challenging. Below are estimations based on standard New York-style pizza metrics.
| Menu Area | Nutrition Note | Best For | Source Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jumbo Slices | Estimated 550–850 calories per slice depending on cheese and meat toppings. | General dietary estimation | Low (Estimates only) |
| The Dough | Made with high-gluten wheat flour, meaning it is carbohydrate-dense. | Understanding macro profiles | Medium |
| Vegetarian Pies | Pies like the Wiseguy substitute heavy meats for spinach and mushrooms, which may slightly reduce total fat. | Lighter dining strategies | Low |
Allergen and Dietary Notes
Goodfellas does not provide an official allergen menu online. Because of the nature of a busy, open-kitchen pizza shop, cross-contact is a significant factor.
| Dietary Need | What to Check | Important Note |
|---|---|---|
| Gluten-Free | Check if your local store offers a 12-inch GF crust. | Flour is everywhere in the kitchen. Cross-contact is highly likely. Not recommended for severe Celiac disease. |
| Vegan | Ask local staff if their dough contains honey, dairy, or egg washes. | You can typically order a veggie pie without cheese, but official vegan status is unconfirmed. |
| Dairy-Free | All standard pizzas and breadsticks use heavy dairy (mozzarella, ricotta, butter). | You must explicitly request no cheese or butter, and cross-contact risk remains high. |
Special Menu Sections
The Wiseguy Lounge & Drinks
Many Goodfellas locations feature a Prohibition-style speakeasy called the "Wiseguy Lounge" attached to the pizzeria.
| Item or Section | What It Includes | Price/Calorie Note | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Craft Cocktails | High-end mixology, Old Fashioneds, and seasonal drinks. | Premium bar pricing | Date nights and weekends |
| Bourbon Selection | Hundreds of rare and regional bourbons. | Varies by the pour | Bourbon enthusiasts |
Catering or Family Meals
If you are planning an event, massive 22-inch pizzas are incredibly efficient. Readers interested in catering options might also review the Bella Napoli Pizzeria catering menu to see how traditional Italian caterers price their trays versus Goodfellas' giant pie strategy.
| Item or Section | What It Includes | Price/Calorie Note | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22" Pies for Groups | One 22" pie generally feeds 3-4 hungry adults. | Cost-effective for crowds | Parties and office lunches |
Best For: Who This Menu Guide Helps
This menu guide is designed to be particularly helpful for:
- Late-night diners trying to find out if single slices are available.
- Budget-conscious eaters looking for lunch combo prices.
- First-time visitors who need to understand exactly how big a 22-inch pizza is before they order one.
- Dietary-conscious readers looking for realistic estimations of calories and cross-contact risks since official info is unavailable.
- Delivery customers wanting to understand why app prices might look inflated compared to the local store menu.
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
To help you get the best value and experience out of your Goodfellas order, keep these practical tips in mind.
- Check the physical box size. If you order a 22-inch pie for pickup, ensure your vehicle has space. The box often will not fit on the floorboards or in a standard home refrigerator!
- Check the official app or local restaurant for exact prices. Menu prices can vary significantly between a downtown entertainment district location and a quieter suburban spot.
- Watch for delivery markups. Third-party delivery prices via DoorDash or UberEats will add service fees and often inflate the actual cost of the pizza. Order direct for pickup to save money.
- Always grab a dipping sauce. Their giant crusts and breadsticks are practically built for dipping. The house-made spicy ranch and garlic butter are highly recommended.
- Ask about the slice of the day. If you want variety without buying a whole pizza, the rotating specialty slice is usually an excellent way to try something new.
- Use caution with allergens. Because they hand-toss pizzas in an open kitchen, airborne flour makes it an unsafe environment for strict Celiac diners.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Goodfellas Pizzeria have a menu with prices?
Goodfellas does not maintain a single, universal price list on its main website because prices vary by city, location type, and delivery platform. You must select your local store in their online ordering portal to see exact pricing.
How big is a Goodfellas jumbo pizza?
Their signature jumbo pizzas are 22 inches in diameter. This is significantly larger than an "extra-large" pie at major national chains, which typically max out at 14 or 16 inches.
Does Goodfellas sell pizza by the slice?
Yes. Selling massive New York-style slices is the core of their business. They typically offer cheese, pepperoni, and a rotating specialty slice.
What is included in the Goodfellas lunch special?
The lunch special usually includes a giant slice of pizza, a side (such as their jumbo breadstick or a side salad), and a fountain drink. It is widely considered their best value.
Where can I find calories for Goodfellas Pizza?
Goodfellas does not currently publish an official calorie matrix or nutritional guide. A 22-inch cheese slice is generally estimated to contain between 550 and 850 calories based on standard pizza sizing.
Does Goodfellas have an allergen menu?
No, there is no official allergen matrix available online. Customers with severe allergies should speak directly with the store manager, keeping in mind that cross-contact in a flour-heavy pizzeria is highly likely.
What are the best things to order at Goodfellas?
Popular items include the Wiseguy (spinach, garlic, mushroom, red onion), The Don (a heavy all-meat pie), and the Jumbo Breadsticks. The Lunch Combo is the best order for value.
Does Goodfellas have gluten-free options?
Many locations offer a 12-inch gluten-free crust for whole pies, though they do not typically offer gluten-free single slices. Cross-contact with regular flour is a risk.
Can I order Goodfellas online or in an app?
Yes, you can order directly through the Goodfellas Pizzeria website or via major third-party delivery apps.
Are delivery prices different from in-store prices?
Yes. Third-party delivery apps like DoorDash and UberEats charge restaurants high commissions, which often results in menu price inflation on those platforms. Ordering pickup directly from Goodfellas is cheaper.
What is the Wiseguy Lounge?
Many Goodfellas locations are split into two concepts: the pizzeria on one side, and the Wiseguy Lounge-a high-end, Prohibition-style bourbon and craft cocktail bar-on the other.
Conclusion
The Goodfellas Pizza menu offers an authentic, oversized New York pizza experience that stands out from standard fast-food chains. Whether you are maximizing value with the lunch special combo, splitting a 22-inch pie with friends, or enjoying a cannoli after dinner in the Wiseguy Lounge, knowing the menu options ensures you get exactly what you want. Since exact prices and daily slice specials change by location, we always recommend checking your local store's online portal before ordering.
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can change by location, time, delivery platform, and restaurant updates. Always confirm the latest information with the official restaurant website, app, or your local restaurant before ordering. Information verified for 2026 where available.
