Italy's Best Pizza Menu with Prices, Calories and Popular Items
Italy’s Best Pizza has earned a reputation as a reliable destination for authentic New York-style pizza. Whether you are visiting a standalone street-side location in North Carolina or Virginia, or grabbing a quick slice at a major mall food court in New Jersey or Florida, the Italy’s Best Pizza menu offers a classic lineup of massive slices, loaded strombolis, and hot Italian subs.
Because Italy’s Best Pizza operates as a collection of independently managed locations rather than a centralized corporate chain, finding accurate online information can be a challenge. This LatestMenus.com guide solves that problem by aggregating data from local store menus, mall directories, and third-party delivery platforms. We have compiled the most helpful look at estimated prices, popular item recommendations, E-E-A-T verified nutrition context, and value-saving tips for 2026. Please remember that because these are independent or regional franchise locations, exact menu availability, daily specials, and prices will always vary by location and delivery platform.
Menu Snapshot: Quick Answer
The Italy's Best Pizza menu features traditional NY-style pizzas, massive calzones, strombolis, and hot Italian subs. Prices typically range from $3.75–$6.50 for a large single slice and $18.00–$26.00 for whole 18-inch specialty pizzas.
Official Source Verification
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can vary by location, delivery platform, and time. LatestMenus checks official restaurant sources where available and marks uncertain information clearly.
Latest Italy's Best Pizza Menu Prices
The following prices are estimates based on compiled current market data for 2026. Prices at mall food courts are typically higher than standalone locations, and delivery apps often add significant markups. Always check your local restaurant for exact local pricing.
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese Pizza (18" Large) | Whole Pizzas | $18.99 – $21.99 | Check official source | Families/Groups | Traditional NY style thin crust |
| Pepperoni Pizza (18" Large) | Whole Pizzas | $20.99 – $23.99 | Check official source | Party sharing | Top-selling whole pie |
| Supreme Pizza | Whole Pizzas | $23.99 – $26.99 | Check official source | Hearty appetites | Loaded with meats and veggies |
| Sicilian Pizza | Whole Pizzas | Varies by location | Check official source | Deep dish fans | Thick-crust, square-cut |
| Single Cheese Slice | Pizza Slices | $3.75 – $5.25 | Check official source | Quick snacks | Giant NY-style cut |
| Gourmet/Specialty Slice | Pizza Slices | $4.95 – $6.50 | Check official source | Quick lunch | e.g., Buffalo Chicken, Meat Lovers |
| Meat Lovers Calzone | Calzones & Rolls | $11.50 – $14.00 | Check official source | Huge portions | Stuffed with ricotta and meats |
| Sausage & Pepper Roll | Calzones & Rolls | $8.50 – $11.00 | Check official source | On-the-go meals | Wrapped in fresh pizza dough |
| Steak & Cheese Sub | Hot Subs | $9.50 – $12.50 | Check official source | Lunch diners | Most praised sandwich option |
| Chicken Parmigiana Sub | Hot Subs | $9.00 – $11.50 | Check official source | Classic Italian fans | Breaded chicken, marinara, cheese |
| Baked Ziti | Pasta Entrees | $10.99 – $13.99 | Check official source | Dinner portions | Often served with garlic bread |
| Garlic Knots (6-piece) | Sides | $4.50 – $5.99 | Check official source | Appetizers | Tossed in garlic butter and herbs |
| Zeppoles | Desserts/Sides | Varies by location | Check official source | Sweet cravings | Fried dough with powdered sugar |
| Garden Salad | Salads | $6.99 – $8.99 | Check official source | Lighter meals | Fresh greens and basic veggies |
Popular Menu Items
While the menu layout is quite extensive, varying slightly depending on if you are at a standalone restaurant or a mall food court, a few staple items stand out as customer favorites across almost all locations.
| Popular Item | Why People Order It | Price Note | Calorie Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Supreme Pizza | Packed with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions, it's the classic "everything" pie. | Premium priced specialty pie | Not published |
| Steak & Cheese Sub | Frequently praised for having high-quality, thinly sliced steak and melted provolone on a well-toasted hero roll. | Varies by location | Not published |
| Meat Lovers Calzone | Known for its massive size and generous filling of ricotta, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, and ham. | Usually around $12.00 | High-calorie item |
| Buffalo Chicken Slice | A staple at mall locations offering a bold mix of spicy chicken, mozzarella base, and a ranch or blue cheese drizzle. | Usually a $1-$2 upcharge over cheese | Not published |
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
These are LatestMenus editorial recommendations based on available menu research, value, popularity, customization potential, and practical ordering usefulness. They are not official restaurant rankings.
The Supreme Pizza
If you are ordering for a group, the Supreme pie offers the best distribution of fresh vegetables and savory meats on top of their classic NY-style thin crust.
2-Slice Combo
A staple at most mall and standalone locations, getting two giant slices of cheese pizza and a large fountain drink is usually the cheapest way to fill up.
18" Cheese Pie & Garlic Knots
Ordering a whole large pie alongside a 6-pack of garlic knots provides plenty of food for a family of four at a lower cost per person than individual pasta dishes.
Garden Salad (Dressing on Side)
Because the menu leans heavily on cheese, dough, and meats, a simple garden salad is the most practical way to reduce heavy carbs if you want a lighter lunch.
Steak & Cheese Sub
It is surprisingly robust for a pizzeria sub, featuring ample shaved steak and cheese on bread that gets a nice crunch from the pizza oven.
Build-Your-Own Calzone
Most locations will gladly let you swap standard meats or veggies in a calzone for no extra charge, making it easy to tailor to your exact cravings.
Cheapest Items and Best Value Picks
If you are looking to stretch your budget, the Italy’s Best Pizza menu has a few reliable deals. Pricing strategies differ depending on whether the store is in a shopping mall with high foot traffic or a local strip mall.
| Value Pick | Why It Can Be Good Value | Watch Out For | Best Ordering Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| The 2-Slice Lunch Combo | Bundles two massive slices and a large drink for less than buying them à la carte. | Some locations restrict this to plain cheese slices only. | Ask if there's an upcharge to make one a pepperoni slice. |
| Garlic Knots (6-Pack) | They are very filling, baked fresh, and usually cost under $6. | They are heavy on carbs and garlic butter. | Add a side of marinara dipping sauce (usually 50 cents extra). |
| Whole 18" Pie | Much cheaper per square inch than buying 3 or 4 individual slices. | Specialty toppings raise the price quickly. | Stick to a 1 or 2 topping pizza to keep the group cost low. |
| Mall Employee Discounts | Mall food courts frequently offer 10-15% off for local mall workers. | You must ask; it is rarely advertised on the menu board. | Show your mall store badge when ordering at the register. |
Calories and Nutrition Notes
Like many independent and regional pizza chains, Italy’s Best Pizza does not publish an official nutrition guide. Because the pizza is hand-tossed and toppings are applied manually, calorie counts can vary significantly from one store to the next.
| Menu Area | Nutrition Note | Best For | Source Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pizza Slices | Not published. Industry averages suggest 350–450 calories per plain cheese slice. | General calorie estimation | Low (Estimates only) |
| Pasta Entrees | Not published. Baked pastas with cheese are typically very calorie-dense (800+ calories). | Tracking heavy carb meals | Low (Estimates only) |
| Salads | Not published. Lighter option, but heavy dressings and cheese can add 300+ calories quickly. | Lower-calorie goals | Low (Estimates only) |
Allergen and Dietary Notes
There is no official corporate allergen guide for Italy’s Best Pizza. Because they operate independent kitchens that heavily feature flour and cheese, customers with severe allergies should exercise extreme caution.
| Dietary Need | What to Check | Important Note |
|---|---|---|
| Gluten/Wheat Allergy | Check if your local store carries gluten-free crusts. | Airborne flour is everywhere in a pizzeria; cross-contact risk is exceptionally high. |
| Dairy Allergy | Check if the pizza dough contains hidden dairy or whey. | Cheese is a primary ingredient in almost all menu items. |
| Vegetarian Options | Check for meatless sauces. | Veggie pizza, cheese pizza, and eggplant parmigiana are standard options. |
| Vegan Options | Check dough ingredients (honey, dairy, eggs). | Vegan options are very limited; you may need to order a salad with oil and vinegar. |
Special Menu Sections
Drinks and Sides
Most locations feature standard fountain sodas (Pepsi or Coca-Cola products depending on the mall/store contract) alongside bottled water and juices. For sides, Garlic Knots are the universal favorite, but many locations also offer Zeppoles (deep-fried dough balls covered in powdered sugar) as a sweet treat.
Value Menu and Deals
While there is no formal "Value Menu," lunch hours (typically 11:00 AM – 3:00 PM at standalone locations) often feature combo deals. You can routinely find discounted prices on a half-sub with a drink, or the classic two-slice combo.
Catering or Family Meals
For large groups, ordering multiple 18" pies is the way to go. Some locations offer basic catering trays of Baked Ziti or Meat Lasagna, but you will need to call your local store at least 24 hours in advance to confirm tray pricing and availability.
| Item or Section | What It Includes | Price/Calorie Note | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Drinks & Sides | Fountain drinks, Knots, Zeppoles, Mozzarella Sticks | Check local store / Calories not published | Adding onto a slice order |
| Lunch Specials | 2-Slice combos, discounted subs | Usually valid 11 AM - 3 PM | Midday breaks and budget dining |
| Pasta Trays | Large portions of Ziti or Lasagna for groups | Requires advance notice | Parties and office catering |
Best For: Who This Menu Guide Helps
This LatestMenus guide is specifically designed to help:
- People checking prices before visiting: Understand the baseline costs for slices vs. whole pies.
- Mall shoppers and workers: Learn about standard combo deals and potential employee discounts.
- People ordering delivery: Be aware that third-party apps frequently mark up prices compared to the in-store menu.
- Diners with dietary concerns: Realize that there is no official allergen guide and cross-contact risk is high for gluten.
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
Make the most of your visit to Italy's Best Pizza with these practical ordering strategies to save money and get the freshest food.
- Check the official app or local restaurant for exact prices. Menu prices can vary significantly between a mall in New Jersey and a street-side shop in North Carolina.
- Compare combos with à la carte items. The 2-slice combo is a great value, but only if you actually want the oversized fountain drink.
- Watch for delivery markups. Third-party delivery prices on DoorDash or UberEats for Italy’s Best are often $2–$4 higher per item than in-store pickup prices.
- Time your slice orders for freshness. In mall locations, the best time for a fresh slice is right before the lunch rush (11:30 AM) or dinner rush (5:30 PM) when they rotate in new pies.
- Ask about mall employee discounts. If you work in the same shopping center, always ask if they offer a localized discount at the register.
- Use caution with allergens. Because there is no official allergen page, always speak to the staff directly if you have a severe gluten or dairy allergy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Italy's Best Pizza have a menu with prices?
There is no centralized corporate menu with uniform prices. Prices vary based on the specific location and whether you are ordering in-person or through a delivery app. A basic cheese slice usually costs between $3.75 and $5.25.
Do prices vary by location?
Yes, heavily. Locations inside large shopping malls frequently charge a premium to cover higher rent costs compared to standalone street-side locations.
Is Italy's Best Pizza a chain?
It operates more as a "loose" chain or a brand name shared by independent regional operators and small franchise groups. If you enjoy regional favorites with similar operational styles, you might also want to check out the Frank's Pizza menu, the Napoleon's Pizza menu, or compare prices to the historic Roseland Apizza menu.
Where can I find calories for Italy's Best Pizza?
Italy’s Best Pizza does not publish an official nutrition or calorie guide. Diners should rely on industry averages for standard New York-style pizza (roughly 350-450 calories per plain cheese slice).
Does Italy's Best Pizza have an allergen menu?
No official allergen menu is available. Gluten and dairy are present in almost all items, and cross-contact is highly likely in their kitchens.
What are the popular items?
The Supreme Pizza, the Meat Lovers Calzone, and the Steak & Cheese Sub are among the most frequently ordered and highly rated items across various locations.
What are the best things to order?
For a quick meal, the 2-Slice Lunch Combo is excellent. For a group, ordering a whole 18" Pepperoni Pizza with a side of Garlic Knots provides the best value and classic flavor.
What are the cheapest/value items?
Garlic Knots (usually under $6 for a half-dozen) and the plain Cheese Pizza by the slice are the most budget-friendly options on the menu.
Can I order online or in the app?
Most locations do not have their own dedicated brand app, but you can usually order online through third-party delivery platforms like DoorDash, Grubhub, or Slice.
Are delivery prices different?
Yes. Prices listed on delivery apps are frequently marked up to cover platform fees. Ordering directly from the store for pick-up is almost always cheaper.
Conclusion
The Italy’s Best Pizza menu delivers exactly what you want from a classic New York-style pizzeria: giant slices, hearty hot subs, and massive strombolis. Because the brand is spread across various independent and mall-based locations, exact menus and prices will fluctuate. For the best value, always look out for slice combos, skip the delivery app markups by picking up your food in person, and verify any allergen concerns directly with your local store's staff.
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can change by location, time, delivery platform, and restaurant updates. Always confirm the latest information with the official restaurant website, app, or your local restaurant before ordering. Information verified for 2026 where available.
