Pan and Peel Pizza Menu with Prices, Calories and Popular Items
Checking the pan and peel pizza menu before you order is the best way to understand your crust choices, compare sizing value, and plan around dietary needs. Known for its distinct dual-cooking approach, Pan and Peel Pizza offers deep-dish pan pies with a thick, buttery base alongside artisan peel-baked pizzas that are launched directly onto hot stones for a crispy, hand-tossed finish.
This guide provides a comprehensive look at the LatestMenus updated prices, estimated calorie ranges, signature items, and practical ordering tips to help you get the best value. Because Pan and Peel Pizza locations operate as regional or independent storefronts, exact menu items, prices, and topping availability will vary by location. Always check your local store's online ordering portal for the most accurate current prices before placing your order.
Menu Snapshot: Quick Answer
Pan and Peel Pizza specializes in both thick deep-dish pan pizzas and thin, stone-baked peel pizzas, with a large specialty pie typically ranging from $21.99 to $24.99 depending on your location. The menu also features oven-roasted wings, cheesy breadsticks, and fresh salads, with prices and exact calorie counts varying by individual store and third-party delivery platform.
Official Source Verification
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can vary by location, delivery platform, and time. LatestMenus checks official restaurant sources where available and marks uncertain information clearly.
Latest Pan and Peel Pizza Menu Prices
The tables below provide estimated standard menu prices, typical calorie ranges per slice, and item notes. Because Pan and Peel Pizza is a locally operated concept, prices are marked as estimates and will vary by location.
Specialty & Signature Pizzas
(Available in buttery Pan Crust or thin stone-baked Peel Crust. Prices reflect typical Small 10" / Medium 12" / Large 14" estimates.)
| Menu Item | Category | Price Range (Sm / Med / Lg) | Calories (Per Slice) | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pan & Peel Supreme | Specialty Pizza | $13.49 / $18.49 / $23.49 (Varies by location) | 280 - 360 kcal | Hearty appetites | Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions |
| All-Meat Feast | Specialty Pizza | $13.99 / $18.99 / $23.99 (Varies by location) | 310 - 410 kcal | High protein | Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, bacon, beef |
| Garlic Peel Pepperoni | Specialty Pizza | $12.99 / $17.99 / $22.99 (Varies by location) | 270 - 350 kcal | Classic pizza lovers | Double pepperoni, roasted garlic, mozzarella |
| Garden Veggie Delight | Specialty Pizza | $11.99 / $16.99 / $21.99 (Varies by location) | 210 - 280 kcal | Vegetarians | Tomatoes, mushrooms, peppers, onions, black olives |
| BBQ Chicken Special | Specialty Pizza | $13.49 / $18.49 / $23.49 (Varies by location) | 260 - 340 kcal | Sweet and savory | Grilled chicken, red onions, BBQ sauce base |
| Classic Margherita | Specialty Pizza | $11.99 / $16.99 / $21.99 (Varies by location) | 200 - 260 kcal | Lighter meals | Fresh basil, mozzarella, olive oil, tomato sauce |
Build Your Own Pizza & Crust Selection
| Selection | Category | Base Price Addition | Calories (Base Crust) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Classic Pan Crust | Crust Option | Included | 220 - 310 kcal/slice | Thick, golden, pan-baked crust |
| Artisan Peel Crust | Crust Option | Included | 160 - 230 kcal/slice | Hand-stretched, crisp, stone-baked |
| Thin & Crispy Crust | Crust Option | Included | 130 - 190 kcal/slice | Extra thin, light cracker-style crust |
| Gluten-Sensitive Crust | Crust Option | +$3.00 (Sm) / +$4.00 (Med) | 150 - 210 kcal/slice | Available in Small or Medium only |
| Extra Topping | Customization | +$1.50 / +$2.00 / +$2.50 | 20 - 90 kcal/slice | Standard meats, cheeses, or fresh veg |
(If you enjoy exploring different artisanal or wood-fired crust options, check out our guide to the Lou's Woodfire Pizza menu or the traditional styles on the Jack's Brick Oven Pizzeria menu).
Wings, Sides & Desserts
| Menu Item | Category | Estimated Price | Estimated Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oven-Roasted Wings (8 pc) | Wings | $10.99 (Varies by location) | 550 - 720 kcal | Buffalo, BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, or Sweet Chili |
| Cheesy Garlic Breadsticks | Side | $6.99 (Varies by location) | 640 kcal (8 pcs) | Brushed with garlic butter, served with marinara |
| House Garden Salad | Salad | $4.99 Side / $8.99 Full | 150 - 350 kcal | Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, croutons |
| Cinnamon Sugar Sticks | Dessert | $5.99 (Varies by location) | 520 kcal (8 pcs) | Topped with sweet icing drizzle |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie Dip | Dessert | $6.99 (Varies by location) | 780 kcal | Warm baked skillet cookie |
Popular Menu Items
When visiting Pan and Peel Pizza for the first time, a few signature items stand out among customer favorites.
| Popular Item | Why People Order It | Price Note | Calorie Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pan & Peel Supreme | The thick pan crust perfectly holds the heavy combination of savory meats and fresh-cut vegetables without getting soggy. | Usually the most expensive specialty tier. | High calorie due to mixed meats. |
| Garlic Peel Pepperoni | Baked on a crisp artisan peel crust and brushed with garlic butter, featuring cup-and-char pepperoni that crisps on the edges. | Mid-tier specialty pricing. | Moderate; lighter than the pan supreme. |
| Oven-Roasted Wings | Finished in high-temperature pizza ovens rather than deep fryers, keeping the chicken tender while caramelizing the sauce. | Priced similarly to casual dining wings. | Varies widely based on chosen sauce. |
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
These are LatestMenus editorial recommendations based on available menu research, value, popularity, customization potential, and practical ordering usefulness. They are not official restaurant rankings.
Pan & Peel Supreme
This crowd favorite provides the best demonstration of the restaurant's signature deep-dish pan dough, holding up perfectly to a heavy load of meats and vegetables.
Large 2-Topping Peel Pizza
Scaling up to a 14-inch pizza yields almost 80% more surface area than a 10-inch small for only about $7 to $8 more, making it the smartest cost-per-slice purchase.
Family Game Night Pack (Combo)
Combining a Large Specialty Pizza, an 8-piece wing order, and cheesy breadsticks in a bundle typically saves $5 to $8 compared to purchasing the items à la carte.
Garden Veggie Delight on Thin Crust
Choosing the thin or peel crust instead of the deep pan crust cuts roughly 60 to 90 calories per slice, and the vegetable toppings keep the fat content low.
Garlic Peel Pepperoni
A classic executed well. The high-heat oven stone gives the peel crust a great char, and the roasted garlic elevates a standard pepperoni pie.
Half-and-Half Pizza Orders
When ordering a medium or large pizza, you can usually split the toppings down the middle at no extra charge, allowing you to satisfy different tastes without buying two small pies.
Cheapest Items and Best Value Picks
Ordering efficiently at Pan and Peel Pizza comes down to choosing the right sizes and looking for local bundles rather than ordering multiple small items.
| Value Pick | Why It Can Be Good Value | Watch Out For | Best Ordering Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Large Pizzas over Small Pizzas | A 14-inch pizza offers nearly 96% more surface area than a 10-inch, but usually costs only 60-70% more. | Over-ordering if dining alone. | Always size up to a Large and save leftovers for lunch. |
| Family Bundles | Bundling wings, sides, and a large pizza can shave $5 to $8 off your total bill. | Combos are only a deal if you actually want all the included items. | Check the "Deals" or "Specials" tab on the online ordering page first. |
| Direct Store Carryout | Avoids 15-20% third-party delivery markups on the base menu items, plus delivery fees. | Requires picking up the food yourself. | Call the store directly or use their official website to secure the lowest menu price. |
(Looking for more ways to save on local favorites? Browse our breakdown of the Red Oven Pizza Bakery menu prices for comparison).
Calories and Nutrition Notes
Caloric content across the Pan and Peel menu varies significantly based on your crust selection and topping density. Official comprehensive nutrition guides are rarely published for independent or regional locations.
| Menu Area | Nutrition Note | Best For | Source Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crust Variations | Pan crust adds significant calories from butter and dough thickness; Peel/Thin crusts save 60-90 kcal per slice. | Calorie-conscious diners | Medium (Estimates only) |
| Meat Toppings | Bacon, sausage, and extra cheese can quickly add 80 to 120 calories per slice. | High protein diets | Medium (Estimates only) |
| Vegetable Toppings | Mushrooms, onions, and peppers add negligible calories (under 15 kcal per slice). | Adding bulk without calories | High (Standard ingredient estimates) |
Allergen and Dietary Notes
Because Pan and Peel Pizza operates as a traditional flour-based pizzeria, cross-contact with major allergens is common. Customers with severe allergies should always speak directly with store management.
| Dietary Need | What to Check | Important Note |
|---|---|---|
| Gluten Sensitivity | Check if your local store offers a gluten-sensitive crust (usually Small or Medium only). | Airborne flour is present in open kitchens; cross-contact with wheat is highly likely. Not recommended for severe Celiac disease. |
| Dairy-Free / Vegan | Request a Thin Peel crust with no cheese, loaded with tomato sauce and fresh vegetables. | Avoid the deep pan crust and garlic butter breadsticks, which contain dairy. Check if plant-based cheese is available locally. |
| Vegetarian | Cheese pizzas, Veggie Supreme, and Garden Salads. | Meat toppings are prepared on shared lines; minor cross-contact can occur. |
Best For: Who This Menu Guide Helps
This menu guide is designed to help:
- Budget-conscious diners checking prices before visiting to plan their meal size.
- Health-conscious eaters comparing the calorie differences between Pan and Peel crusts.
- Families looking for the best meal combos and value bundles.
- Delivery customers wanting to understand potential markup differences between in-store and app prices.
- Individuals with dietary concerns who need to know about gluten cross-contact risks before ordering.
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
Use these practical strategies to ensure you get the freshest food and the best value on your next Pan and Peel Pizza order.
- Check the official local restaurant for exact prices. Menu prices can vary by city, restaurant, and delivery platform. Third-party apps often inflate item costs.
- Compare combos with à la carte items. A family meal pack can be better value, but only if you actually want the drinks and side items included.
- Match your crust to your toppings. Pair heavy, loaded meat toppings with the sturdy Deep Pan crust. Thin or Peel crusts perform best with lighter topping combinations.
- Watch for delivery markups. Third-party delivery prices and fees may be up to 20% higher than in-store or pickup prices.
- Use official nutrition and allergen pages before ordering. This is especially important if severe allergens or cross-contact matter to you, as kitchen practices vary.
- Reheat leftovers properly. Reheat pan pizza in a skillet on medium heat for 3 to 4 minutes to crisp the bottom crust, then cover for 1 minute to melt the top cheese.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary difference between Pan crust and Peel crust?
Pan crust is deep-dish style, baked inside a buttered steel pan for a thick interior and golden outer crust. Peel crust is a traditional hand-stretched crust launched directly onto a hot stone with a wooden peel, producing a thinner, crispier texture.
Does Pan and Peel Pizza have a menu with prices?
Yes, but because locations are often independent or regional, exact prices vary. A large specialty pizza typically ranges between $21.99 and $24.99. Check your local store's portal for accurate pricing.
Are prices higher on delivery apps than in the store?
Yes. Delivery platforms like DoorDash and Uber Eats usually list marked-up menu prices (often 15% to 20% higher) to cover platform commissions, plus extra delivery fees. Ordering carryout directly from the store provides the best pricing.
Where can I find calories for Pan and Peel Pizza?
Official, exact calorie counts are often not published centrally for independent locations. However, standard estimates show a large Pan crust slice runs 280-360 calories, while Peel crust slices are typically 60-90 calories lighter.
Does Pan and Peel Pizza have an allergen menu?
Most locations do not publish a comprehensive national allergen matrix. While gluten-sensitive crusts are offered at participating locations, pizzas are prepared in shared kitchens with airborne flour, making cross-contact highly likely.
What are the popular items to order?
Customer favorites include the Pan & Peel Supreme on a thick crust, the Garlic Peel Pepperoni on a crispy stone-baked crust, and Oven-Roasted Wings.
Can I order half-and-half toppings on a pizza?
Yes, half-and-half customization is widely supported on medium and large pizzas across both pan and peel crust styles, usually at no extra base charge.
What are the cheapest or best value items?
The best value comes from sizing up: a Large 14-inch pizza offers almost double the food of a Small 10-inch for only a fraction more in price. Family combos with breadsticks and wings also offer great bundle savings.
Conclusion
The pan and peel pizza menu offers a highly customizable experience, letting you choose between thick, buttery pan pies and classic, stone-baked peel crusts. To get the best value, always calculate the price-per-size by ordering large pizzas for leftovers, check your local store for family bundles, and opt for direct carryout to avoid delivery app markups.
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can change by location, time, delivery platform, and restaurant updates. Always confirm the latest information with the official restaurant website, app, or your local restaurant before ordering. Information verified for 2026 where available.
