Nick & Bruno's Pizzeria Menu with Prices, Calories and Popular Items
When looking for the perfect slice or a massive pie to feed a crowd, the Nick & Bruno's Pizzeria menu delivers authentic, comforting Italian-American classics. Because this name is shared by two highly popular, yet independent, local pizzerias, this guide covers the distinct offerings of both fan-favorite locations: the Spencerport, New York location (famous for massive Rochester-style sheet pizzas and jumbo wings) and the Wellsboro, Pennsylvania location (celebrated for its hand-tossed NY-style thin crusts and stuffed strombolis).
Whether you want to check menu prices, see what size a traditional sheet pizza is, find gluten-free options, or discover the best things to order, this guide has you covered. Prices and availability vary by location and delivery platform, so it is always a good idea to call your local shop or check their official online ordering portal before placing an order.
If you are exploring other great regional independent pizzerias, you may also want to check out the Nick's Place Saugus menu, the classic Jack's Brick Oven Pizzeria menu, or the Monte Bello Pizzeria menu for comparison.
Menu Snapshot: Quick Answer
Nick & Bruno's Pizzeria serves highly-rated classic pizzas, wings, subs, and Italian dinners. While exact prices vary depending on if you order from the NY or PA location, both spots offer fantastic value for large families.
Official Source Verification
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can vary by location, delivery platform, and time. LatestMenus checks official restaurant sources where available and marks uncertain information clearly.
Latest Nick & Bruno's Pizzeria Menu Prices
Because there are two distinct, highly popular independent pizzerias operating under the "Nick & Bruno's" name, we have separated their menus below. Prices are estimates based on active local online ordering portals like Slice and are subject to change.
Spencerport, NY Menu (Rochester-Style & Sheet Pizzas)
The Spencerport location is beloved in Upstate New York for its massive, 32-slice rectangular sheet pizzas, hot subs, and jumbo crispy chicken wings.
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Personal Pizza (10") | Pizzas | $9.99 – $11.99 | Not published | Individual meals | Traditional round pie |
| Medium Pizza (14") | Pizzas | $14.99 – $16.99 | Not published | 2-3 People | Highly customizable |
| Large Pizza (16") | Pizzas | $17.99 – $20.99 | Not published | Family dinner | Local favorite |
| Sheet Pizza (32 Slices) | Pizzas | $28.99 – $34.99 | Not published | Parties / Large groups | Authentic Rochester rectangular style |
| Gluten-Free Pizza (12") | Pizzas | $13.99 – $15.99 | Not published | Gluten-sensitive diners | Shared kitchen cross-contact risk applies |
| Single Jumbo Wings (10 pcs) | Wings | $13.99 – $15.99 | Not published | Appetizers | Served with blue cheese and celery |
| Double Jumbo Wings (20 pcs) | Wings | $25.99 – $28.99 | Not published | Sharing | Up to two sauce flavors |
| Bucket Jumbo Wings (50 pcs) | Wings | $58.99 – $64.99 | Not published | Game day | Great value for feeding a crowd |
Wellsboro, PA Menu (NY-Style, Strombolis & Subs)
The Wellsboro location focuses heavily on hand-tossed NY-style round pizzas, thick-cut Sicilian deep dish, folded calzones, and stuffed strombolis.
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional Cheese Pizza (16") | NY Pizzas | $16.50 – $18.50 | Not published | Sharing | Classic thin, foldable crust |
| Sicilian Cheese Pizza | Pizzas | $19.00 – $21.00 | Not published | Hearty appetites | Thick, airy, square pan pizza |
| The Works / Supreme (Med-XL) | Specialty | $18.50 – $26.00 | Not published | Loaded toppings lovers | Pepperoni, sausage, veg |
| Buffalo Chicken Pizza | Specialty | $17.50 – $24.50 | Not published | Spicy food fans | Grilled chicken, hot sauce, ranch/blue cheese |
| Steak Stromboli | Strombolis | $11.50 – $16.50 | Not published | Big appetites | Shaved ribeye, onions, peppers, mozzarella |
| Philly Cheesesteak Sub | Hot Subs | $9.50 – $12.00 | Not published | Lunch | Served on a toasted Italian roll |
| Garlic Knots (12 pcs) | Appetizers | $8.00 | Not published | Sides | Tossed in garlic oil, parmesan, parsley |
| Baked Ziti | Pasta | $13.50 – $16.00 | Not published | Dinner | Penne baked with ricotta and mozzarella |
Popular Menu Items
While the locations differ slightly in style, both serve authentic, highly-rated Italian-American classics. Here is what locals order most often.
| Popular Item | Why People Order It | Price Note | Calorie Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rochester-Style Sheet Pizza (NY) | With 32 square slices, it is the ultimate party food with a slightly thicker, bread-like crust. | $28.99 – $34.99 | Not published |
| Traditional NY Cheese Pizza (PA) | A perfect balance of sweet-savory marinara and high-grade low-moisture mozzarella with a foldable crust. | $16.50 – $18.50 (Large) | Not published |
| Philly Cheesesteak Sub | Generously packed with shaved ribeye steak, caramelized onions, and melted cheese on a fresh roll. | $9.50 – $12.00 | Not published |
| Jumbo Buffalo Wings | Crispy on the outside, tossed in signature sauces (Mild, Hot, BBQ, Garlic Parm), and served with blue cheese. | $12.50 – $15.99 (10 pcs) | Not published |
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
These are LatestMenus editorial recommendations based on available menu research, value, popularity, customization potential, and practical ordering usefulness. They are not official restaurant rankings.
The Rochester Sheet Pizza (Spencerport)
If you are near the NY location, the 32-slice rectangular sheet pizza is an absolute must-order. It is the gold standard for regional pizza parties.
Garlic Knots (Wellsboro)
For just a few dollars, a half-dozen freshly baked garlic knots tossed in parmesan and oil provide an incredibly filling and flavorful side.
Sheet Pizza & Double Wings Combo
Ordering a sheet pizza and 20 wings covers a massive amount of food for a fraction of the cost of ordering multiple round pies and individual entrees.
White Garlic Pizza
Made with olive oil, fresh garlic, ricotta, and mozzarella (no heavy red sauce), this is a flavorful vegetarian option that feels slightly less heavy than meat-loaded pies.
Steak Stromboli (Wellsboro)
A massive, folded, and baked dough pocket stuffed with shaved ribeye, onions, and cheese. It is a hearty alternative to a standard pizza slice.
Jumbo Chicken Wings
With sauces ranging from traditional Hot to Garlic Parmesan and Sweet Chili, you can customize your crispiness level and sauce mix to match your exact taste.
Cheapest Items and Best Value Picks
As local independent shops, both Nick & Bruno's locations offer generous portions that provide excellent value if you know how to order.
| Value Pick | Why It Can Be Good Value | Watch Out For | Best Ordering Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Half-Dozen Garlic Knots | At around $4.50 to $5.00, it is a very cheap, carb-heavy appetizer that easily satisfies 2-3 people. | Marinara sauce may be an extra charge if you request a larger cup. | Add these to any salad order to make it a full, filling meal. |
| Counter Pizza Slices | During lunch hours, grabbing 1-2 standard slices is much cheaper than buying a whole personal pie. | Slices are usually limited to Cheese or Pepperoni and depend on counter availability. | Call ahead right before the lunch rush to ensure fresh slices are coming out. |
| Daily Sub Specials | Local pizzerias frequently run weekday lunch specials packaging a hot sub with chips and a drink. | These specials often expire after 2:00 PM or 3:00 PM. | Check their Facebook page or Slice app for the daily rotating sub deal. |
Calories and Nutrition Notes
Because Nick & Bruno's Pizzeria locations operate as independent small businesses, they do not publish official nutritional information or calorie charts.
| Menu Area | Nutrition Note | Best For | Source Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pizzas & Slices | Not officially published. A standard slice of NY cheese pizza typically ranges from 250–350 calories. | General estimation | Low (Estimates only) |
| Pasta Dinners | Not officially published. Baked pasta dishes with cheese and meat generally exceed 900+ calories. | Hearty meals | Low (Estimates only) |
| Wings | Fried wings and heavy cream-based dipping sauces add significant calories. Order grilled/dry-rub if tracking macros. | Calorie-conscious ordering | Low (Estimates only) |
Allergen and Dietary Notes
If you have severe food allergies, it is critical to understand how local pizzerias operate.
| Dietary Need | What to Check | Important Note |
|---|---|---|
| Gluten-Free Options | Both locations typically offer a 12-inch gluten-free or cauliflower crust option. | Because wheat flour is heavily used in the kitchen, severe cross-contact risk exists. Not recommended for strict Celiac disease. |
| Dairy Allergies | Mozzarella, ricotta, and parmesan are foundational ingredients across the menu. | You can request a "tomato pie" (pizza with sauce but no cheese), but inform staff of the allergy so they use clean cutters. |
| Nut & Egg Allergies | Most standard pizzas are nut-free, but meatballs and baked goods may contain eggs/breadcrumbs. | Always ask the manager directly about ingredient lists for processed items like meatballs and desserts before ordering. |
Special Menu Sections
Subs and Hoagies
Hot and cold subs are a massive draw at both locations. The Chicken Parmigiana and Philly Cheesesteak are served on freshly baked, toasted Italian rolls and come generously portioned.
Wings and Sides
Upstate New York is famous for its wing culture. At the Spencerport location, wings are fried crispy and traditionally served with thick blue cheese dressing and celery. You can order them in single (10), double (20), or bucket (50) quantities.
Best For: Who This Menu Guide Helps
This guide is designed to help:
- Families checking prices and sizing for Rochester-style sheet pizzas before hosting a party.
- Locals wanting to know the difference between the PA and NY menus.
- People ordering delivery who want to know about potential third-party markups.
- Diners with gluten sensitivities looking for crust options and cross-contact warnings.
- Budget-conscious students looking for the cheapest, most filling items like subs and garlic knots.
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
Use these practical tips to get the best value, freshest food, and most accurate pricing when ordering from Nick & Bruno's.
- Check the official app or local restaurant for exact prices. Menu prices can vary significantly between the NY and PA locations, and third-party apps will add markups.
- Call ahead for sheet pizzas. A 32-slice sheet pizza takes significantly longer to prepare and bake than a standard round pie. Call 2 to 3 hours in advance on busy weekends.
- Watch for delivery markups. Ordering directly through their preferred local portal (like Slice) or calling the store directly is usually cheaper than using national apps like DoorDash or Grubhub.
- Use official nutrition and allergen pages before ordering. Since local shops don't publish official charts, you must ask the manager directly if calories, allergens, or cross-contact matter to you.
- Customize your wing sauces. Don't be afraid to ask for regional mixes, like "Buffalo Garlic," or request your wings "extra crispy."
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Nick & Bruno's Pizzeria have a menu with prices online?
Yes, you can view estimated menu prices via their official ordering partners like Slice and Menufy, but exact prices are subject to change and local delivery markups.
Do prices vary by location?
Yes, significantly. The Spencerport, NY and Wellsboro, PA locations operate as independent local restaurants with distinct menus, pricing structures, and regional specialties.
Where can I find calories for Nick & Bruno's Pizzeria?
Because they are independent local pizzerias, they do not publish official calorie or nutritional information.
Does Nick & Bruno's Pizzeria have an allergen menu?
No official allergen menu is published. Always ask the staff directly regarding ingredients and cross-contamination risks before placing an order.
How many slices are in a Nick & Bruno's sheet pizza?
The Spencerport, NY location serves a traditional Rochester-style rectangular sheet pizza cut into 32 square slices, which easily feeds 8 to 12 people.
Does Nick & Bruno's offer gluten-free crusts?
Yes, they typically offer a 12-inch gluten-free or cauliflower crust. However, they bake in shared ovens, meaning cross-contact with wheat flour is highly likely.
What are the most popular items?
The Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Steak Stromboli, Rochester Sheet Pizza, Philly Cheesesteak Sub, and Jumbo Buffalo Wings are the most frequently ordered items.
What are the cheapest items on the menu?
Pizza slices at the lunch counter, Garlic Knots, and French Fries are the cheapest and most filling side items available.
Can I order online or in the app?
Yes, both locations partner with online ordering portals like the Slice app and local delivery services for convenient takeout and delivery.
Are delivery prices different?
Yes. If you use a third-party app like DoorDash or UberEats, the menu prices are often marked up to cover platform fees compared to ordering directly from the restaurant.
Conclusion
Nick & Bruno's Pizzeria is a staple for massive portions, fantastic regional pizza styles, and crispy wings. Whether you are ordering a massive 32-slice sheet pizza in Spencerport or a stuffed stromboli in Wellsboro, you are guaranteed authentic Italian-American comfort food. Always use their preferred local ordering portals or call ahead to lock in the best prices and ensure your order is fresh.
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can change by location, time, delivery platform, and restaurant updates. Always confirm the latest information with the official restaurant website, app, or your local restaurant before ordering. Information verified for 2026 where available.
