George's Pizza Niagara Falls Menu with Prices, Calories and Popular Items
Looking for the complete george's pizza niagara falls menu before placing your next lunch or dinner order? As a beloved independent pizzeria in Western New York, George's Pizza is famous for serving authentic regional favorite pizza, crispy Buffalo-style chicken wings, massive sheet pizzas for large gatherings, and hot oven-baked subs. Whether you are a local resident placing a quick pickup order or a tourist visiting the Niagara Falls region seeking an affordable family meal, having accurate menu information helps you choose the best options within your budget.
This comprehensive guide covers updated menu prices, popular local specialty items, group ordering value picks, calorie estimates, allergen warnings, and practical money-saving ordering tips. Please note that exact item availability and pricing may vary slightly depending on whether you order in-person, over the phone, via direct online portals like Slice, or through third-party delivery services such as DoorDash or UberEats.
If you are a fan of this specific style of Western New York pizza, you might also find similarities when comparing it to a Just Pizza menu in nearby Buffalo, or checking out the broader George's Pizza restaurant menu footprint. For those exploring other upstate New York styles, looking at the Tony's Pizzeria Utica menu offers a great contrast in regional flavors.
Official Source Verification
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can vary by location, delivery platform, and time. LatestMenus checks official restaurant sources where available and marks uncertain information clearly.
Latest George's Pizza Menu Prices
The following prices reflect standard direct-order takeout rates for George's Pizza in Niagara Falls. Keep in mind that prices will likely be higher if you use a third-party delivery service. Calories are estimated based on standard independent pizzeria prep methods, as official nutrition facts are not published.
1. Traditional & Specialty Pizzas
Pizzas are generally available in Personal/Small, Medium, Large, and Full Sheet (Party Slab) sizes.
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese Pizza | Pizzas | $11.99 - $34.99 | ~280 kcal/slice | Classic sharing | Signature house tomato sauce and mozzarella |
| Cup-and-Char Pepperoni Pizza | Pizzas | $13.99 - $38.99 | ~330 kcal/slice | Regional flavor | WNY regional favorite featuring crispy pepperoni cups |
| White Garlic Pizza | Specialty Pizzas | $14.99 - $24.99 | ~310 kcal/slice | Vegetarians | Olive oil, garlic, oregano, mozzarella, ricotta base |
| Deluxe / The Works Pizza | Specialty Pizzas | $16.99 - $28.99 | ~360 kcal/slice | Large appetites | Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions |
| Meat Lovers Pizza | Specialty Pizzas | $16.99 - $28.99 | ~390 kcal/slice | High protein | Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, ground beef |
| Buffalo Chicken Pizza | Specialty Pizzas | $16.99 - $27.99 | ~350 kcal/slice | Spicy flavor | Diced chicken in hot/medium sauce over a blue cheese base |
| Veggie Supreme Pizza | Specialty Pizzas | $15.99 - $25.99 | ~260 kcal/slice | Vegetarians | Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives |
2. Authentic Buffalo Wings & Chicken Fingers
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional Buffalo Wings (10 Count) | Wings | ~$14.99 | ~900 kcal total | Individual meal | Served with real blue cheese and celery |
| Traditional Buffalo Wings (20 Count) | Wings | ~$27.99 | ~1,800 kcal total | Sharing for 2 | Mild, Medium, Hot, BBQ, or Garlic Parm options |
| Traditional Buffalo Wings (50 Count) | Wings | ~$59.99 | ~4,500 kcal total | Parties | Group size, includes extra blue cheese cups |
| Boneless Wings (10 Piece) | Wings | ~$12.99 | ~750 kcal total | No mess eating | Crispy breaded boneless chicken bites |
| Chicken Fingers & Fries (5 Piece) | Appetizers | ~$13.99 | ~1,100 kcal total | Kids / picky eaters | Includes fresh fries, blue cheese, and choice of sauce |
3. Hot & Cold Subs, Panzerottis & Calzones
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steak Sub (Western NY Style) | Hot Subs (12") | ~$12.99 | ~950 kcal | Hearty lunch | Ribeye steak, melted cheese, onions, and peppers |
| Chicken Parm Sub | Hot Subs (12") | ~$11.99 | ~880 kcal | Classic Italian sub | Breaded chicken cutlet, marinara, melted mozzarella |
| Classic Cold Cut / Assorted Sub | Cold Subs (12") | ~$10.99 | ~780 kcal | Quick cold lunch | Ham, salami, capicola, provolone, and veggies |
| Baked Cheese Calzone | Specialty | ~$12.99 | ~900 kcal | Alternative to pizza | Stuffed dough with ricotta, mozzarella, side of sauce |
| Fried Panzerotti | Specialty | ~$11.99 | ~850 kcal | Savory comfort food | Golden fried turnover filled with cheese and sauce |
Popular Menu Items
When ordering from George's Pizza in Niagara Falls, several regional options consistently rank as customer favorites. Because Western New York is renowned for its specific take on pizza and wings, these staples are ordered daily by both locals and visiting tourists.
| Popular Item | Why People Order It | Price Note | Calorie Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cup-and-Char Pepperoni Pizza | Authentic Niagara/Buffalo regional style. The small pepperoni slices curl into crisp cups that hold savory oils. | Varies by pizza size | ~330 kcal per slice |
| Traditional Medium Buffalo Wings | Prepared true to local standards-crispy skin, classic butter/hot sauce blend, served with real blue cheese. | ~$14.99 per 10 count | ~90 kcal per wing (unsauced) |
| Western NY Steak Sub | A local staple featuring seared ribeye, melted cheese, and oil/seasoning baked on a fresh sub roll. | ~$12.99 (Whole) | ~950 kcal |
| Buffalo Chicken Specialty Pizza | Combines crispy chicken and spicy wing sauce over a creamy blue cheese base. | Varies by pizza size | ~350 kcal per slice |
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
These are LatestMenus editorial recommendations based on available menu research, local popularity, value, customization potential, and practical ordering usefulness at George's Pizza. They are not official restaurant rankings.
Cup-and-Char Pepperoni Large Pizza
This is the definitive taste of Western New York pizza. The thicker crust, rich sweet-savory sauce, and crispy pepperoni cups offer the best representation of the restaurant's quality.
Pizza & Wing Combos
Purchasing a Large Pizza alongside 20 Traditional Wings as a bundled combo saves roughly 12% to 15% compared to ringing them up separately.
Full Party Sheet Pizza
Baked in a large rectangular pan and cut into 32 square slices, a sheet pizza easily feeds 6 to 10 people and provides the lowest cost-per-slice on the menu.
Veggie Supreme Pizza
While pizzeria fare is inherently indulgent, the Veggie Supreme avoids heavy processed meats and piles on fresh mushrooms, peppers, onions, and olives for a more balanced bite.
Traditional Medium Buffalo Wings
Cooked crisp and tossed in classic sauce, these are quintessential regional wings. They are served properly with celery and chunky blue cheese dip.
Baked Cheese Calzone
A massive pocket of pizza dough stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella. You can customize it by adding any pizza topping to the filling before baking.
Cheapest Items and Best Value Picks
If you want to maximize your budget-especially when feeding a family or a tourist group visiting Niagara Falls-prioritize these strategic value options:
| Value Pick | Why It Can Be Good Value | Watch Out For | Best Ordering Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pizza & Wing Combos | Bundling a large pie with 20+ wings drops the overall price compared to ordering items individually. | Delivery app markups often erase combo savings. | Call the store directly to ask about unlisted daily specials. |
| Full Sheet Pizza (32 Slices) | Drops the average cost per slice down to roughly $1.10 - $1.20. | It takes longer to bake; order ahead of time during peak hours. | You can usually split toppings half-and-half on a sheet pie. |
| Classic Cold Cut Sub | At around $10.99 for a full 12-inch sub, it provides excellent volume and calorie-to-price ratio for a single meal. | Adding extra meat or cheese increases the price. | Order it "fully loaded" with all free veggie toppings to maximize the size. |
Calories and Nutrition Notes
As an independent, single-location pizzeria, George's Pizza is not required by federal regulations to publish standard nutrition panels or exact calorie counts. The density of cheese, dough thickness, and sauce volumes can vary slightly from order to order.
The figures below are generalized estimates based on standard regional independent pizza preparation.
| Menu Area | Nutrition Note | Best For | Source Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese Pizza Slice (Large 16") | Estimated ~280 - 340 kcal per slice. | Baseline calorie tracking | Low (Estimation only) |
| Pepperoni Pizza Slice | Estimated ~320 - 380 kcal per slice. Cup-and-char pepperoni holds more oil. | Standard meal planning | Low (Estimation only) |
| Buffalo Wings | Estimated ~80 - 100 kcal per plain wing. Sauces and butter add more. | High protein, low carb | Low (Estimation only) |
| Blue Cheese Dip | Adds ~150 - 200 kcal per 2oz ramekin. | Flavor enhancement | Low (Estimation only) |
Health Tip: To reduce total calories or fat, opt for a thin-crust preparation, ask for "light cheese," or request your wings be tossed in hot sauce without added butter or with sauce entirely on the side.
Allergen and Dietary Notes
George's Pizza prepares foods containing common dietary allergens in a traditional open-kitchen environment. Official allergen documentation is not published. Guests with severe allergies or strict dietary restrictions must contact the kitchen directly before ordering.
| Dietary Need | What to Check | Important Note |
|---|---|---|
| Gluten / Wheat Allergies | Ask about 10-inch or 12-inch gluten-free crust availability. | Because pizzas are made in an open kitchen with airborne flour, extreme cross-contamination risk exists. Not recommended for severe Celiacs. |
| Dairy / Milk | Present in mozzarella, ricotta, garlic butter, and blue cheese. | You can order a custom pizza "Tomato Pie" style (sauce only, no cheese) for a dairy-free base. |
| Vegetarian Options | Veggie Supreme, White Pizza, Cheese Calzones, Mozzarella Sticks. | Confirm that the fryer used for appetizers is not shared with meat items if you are strictly vegetarian. |
| Soy & Eggs | Check frying oils and mayonnaise used on cold subs. | Many independent pizzerias use blended soy oils for deep frying wings and appetizers. |
Special Menu Sections
Catering or Family Meals
If you are planning an event, hotel gathering, or family meal near Niagara Falls, George's Pizza provides excellent bulk options.
| Item or Section | What It Includes | Price/Calorie Note | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Party Sheet Pizzas | A massive rectangular pizza cut into 32 uniform square slices. | Usually starts around $32 - $35 for cheese | Feeding 6 to 10 people easily |
| 50-Count Wing Platters | A tray of 50 traditional wings, ample celery, and multiple blue cheese dips. | Usually starting around $59.99 | Sports viewing parties and large groups |
| Split-Sauce Wings | Large orders can often be split into two flavors (e.g., half Medium, half Garlic Parm). | No extra charge for standard split flavors | Groups with mixed spice tolerances |
Best For: Who This Menu Guide Helps
This menu guide is designed to help several types of readers:
- Locals and Tourists: People checking current local price ranges before visiting or calling in an order.
- Budget-Conscious Diners: Families looking for the best value picks, like combo deals and sheet pizzas.
- Delivery Customers: People wanting to understand why delivery apps charge more and how to avoid surprise markups by calling direct.
- Health-Conscious Eaters: Diners needing a rough estimate of calories since official nutrition facts aren't published.
- Allergy Sufferers: People with dietary concerns who need to understand the cross-contact risks at an independent pizzeria.
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
To get the best quality food and lowest prices from George's Pizza in Niagara Falls, follow these practical ordering strategies.
- Check the official app or local restaurant for exact prices. Menu prices can vary by city, restaurant, and delivery platform. Ordering directly by calling the store or using their preferred Slice portal is almost always cheaper.
- Watch for delivery markups. Third-party delivery prices and fees (DoorDash, UberEats) may be 15% to 20% higher than in-store or direct pickup prices.
- Compare combos with à la carte items. A pizza and wing combo can be a much better value, but only if your group actually plans to eat the full volume of wings provided.
- Request wings "crispy" with sauce on the side for travel. If you are taking the food back to a hotel near the Falls, this prevents the wing skin from getting soggy in the takeout box.
- Blue cheese is the local standard. In Western New York, wings are served with blue cheese. If you want ranch, you must explicitly ask for it.
- Use official nutrition and allergen pages before ordering. This is especially important if calories, allergens, or cross-contact matter to you, though independent shops require a direct phone call to the kitchen for verification.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does George's Pizza in Niagara Falls have a menu with prices?
Yes, you can view standard prices by calling the store directly or checking their official integration on the Slice ordering app. Keep in mind that prices printed on older physical menus may be outdated due to food supply cost changes.
Do prices vary by location or delivery platform?
Yes. Prices are generally cheapest if you walk in or call for pickup. Ordering delivery through third-party apps like DoorDash or Grubhub will typically result in higher per-item prices and added service fees.
How much is a Large Pizza at George's Pizza Niagara Falls?
A standard Large Cheese Pizza ranges between $18.99 and $21.99, with additional toppings priced around $2.25 to $3.00 each depending on the topping type.
Where can I find official calories for the menu?
George's Pizza is an independent, single-location business and is not required by law to publish official calorie counts. Any nutritional data found online for the restaurant is purely an estimate.
Does George's Pizza have an allergen menu?
No official allergen menu is published. Guests must assume that wheat, dairy, and soy are present in the kitchen and that cross-contamination is highly likely. Always alert the staff to severe allergies before paying.
What are the most popular items?
The Cup-and-Char Pepperoni Pizza, Traditional Buffalo Wings tossed in Medium sauce, and the hot Steak Sub are among the most frequently ordered items.
What are the best things to order for a group?
If you are feeding 5 or more people, ordering a Full Party Sheet Pizza alongside a 20 or 50-count order of Traditional Wings offers the best value and variety.
Does George's Pizza offer gluten-free options?
Gluten-free crust options (usually in a 10-inch or 12-inch size) are generally available upon request. However, because the kitchen processes regular flour heavily, it is not considered safe for those with severe Celiac disease.
What are the cheapest or best value items?
For individual lunches, the Cold Cut Subs offer a massive amount of food for around $10.99. For dinner, Pizza and Wing combo packages provide the highest percentage of savings.
Does George's Pizza serve authentic Buffalo wings?
Yes. Niagara Falls and Buffalo share the exact same regional wing culture. Wings here are fried crisp, tossed in traditional butter-and-hot-sauce mixtures, and served with true blue cheese and celery.
Can I order online or in the app?
Yes, George's Pizza typically partners with the Slice app for direct local online ordering, which is heavily preferred over standard third-party delivery apps.
Are delivery prices different?
Yes. If you use DoorDash, UberEats, or Grubhub, expect the base price of pizzas and wings to be marked up by roughly $1.50 to $4.00 per item to cover the app's commission fees.
Conclusion
Whether you are craving a local favorite like cup-and-char pepperoni pizza or need a massive sheet pie to feed your family after a long day sightseeing, George's Pizza in Niagara Falls delivers classic Western New York comfort food. To maximize your value, always try to order directly by phone or via their preferred Slice app to avoid hidden delivery markups, and look out for bundled pizza and wing combos.
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can change by location, time, delivery platform, and restaurant updates. Always confirm the latest information with the official restaurant website, app, or your local restaurant before ordering. Information verified for 2026 where available.
