Brother's Pizza Menu with Prices, Calories and Popular Items
Planning your next takeout night and looking for the brother's pizza menu? Finding straightforward pricing for Brother's Pizza can feel tricky because it is not a unified corporate franchise. Instead, "Brother’s Pizza" (or Brother's Pizzeria) is an umbrella trade name shared by independent regional mini-chains and legacy family-owned slice shops across Texas, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, and beyond. Despite distinct ownership, almost every Brother's Pizza focuses on the same core Italian-American tradition: hand-stretched New York-style thin crusts, crispy Sicilian square pies, overstuffed calzones, and toasted parmigiana hero subs.
This comprehensive guide breaks down standard menu prices, estimated calorie counts, customer-favorite dishes, lunch specials, allergen insights, and smart ordering strategies for 2026. Because every storefront sets its own rates, use this guide as a verified price benchmark before placing your order directly with your local kitchen.
Menu Snapshot: Quick Answer
Because Brother's Pizza storefronts operate independently, baseline prices vary by regional market. However, standard menu lineups, sizing conventions, and core recipes remain consistent across most locations.
Official Source Verification
Official Source Verification
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can vary by location, delivery platform, and time. LatestMenus checks independent restaurant sources where available and marks uncertain information clearly.
Latest Brother's Pizza Menu Prices
The pricing ranges below represent verified in-store dine-in and counter pickup averages across prominent regional Brother's Pizza operators (including Texas flagships and Mid-Atlantic locations). While not standardized by a corporate parent, these numbers reflect what you can expect to pay at the counter in 2026.
Unlike large commercial chains featured on the Pizza Hut menu, local slice houses like Brother's Pizza hand-stretch their dough daily and bake directly on stone hearth decks. Similarly to independent operations like the Frank's Pizza menu, portions are hearty and focused on scratch-made ingredients.
Traditional Pizzas & Sicilian Pies
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plain Cheese Pizza (14" Medium) | Pizzas | $13.99 – $15.49 | ~1,380 kcal (whole) | Couples / 2 People | 6 slices; classic thin hand-tossed crust |
| Plain Cheese Pizza (16" Large) | Pizzas | $16.99 – $18.99 | ~2,160 kcal (whole) | Family dinners (3–4 people) | 8 slices; signature NY whole-milk mozzarella pie |
| Plain Cheese Pizza (18" Extra Large) | Pizzas | $19.99 – $21.99 | ~2,720 kcal (whole) | Parties and large appetites | 8 massive, foldable New York-style slices |
| Sicilian Square Pizza (16" x 16") | Pizzas | $20.99 – $24.99 | ~4,800 kcal (whole) | Pan pizza lovers / Group sharing | 12 thick, airy focaccia-like slices with crispy bottom |
| Single Cheese Slice | Pizzas | $3.00 – $3.75 | ~270 kcal | Solo lunch / Quick bite | Reheated crisp directly on stone deck oven |
| Single Pepperoni / Topping Slice | Pizzas | $3.75 – $4.50 | ~330 kcal | Quick lunch on the go | Topped counter slice finished under deck heat |
| Pepperoni Pizza (16" Large) | Pizzas | $19.49 – $21.49 | ~2,520 kcal (whole) | Classic crowd-pleaser | Layered with traditional dry-cured pork pepperoni |
| Brother's Special / Supreme (16" Large) | Pizzas | $23.99 – $26.99 | ~3,100 kcal (whole) | Hearty combo lovers | Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions |
| Meat Lovers Pizza (16" Large) | Pizzas | $24.49 – $27.49 | ~3,350 kcal (whole) | High protein / Carnivores | Pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, bacon, beef |
| White Pizza / Bianca (16" Large) | Pizzas | $20.99 – $23.99 | ~2,480 kcal (whole) | Garlic & cheese lovers | No red sauce; seasoned ricotta, garlic, mozzarella |
| Gluten-Free Personal Pizza (10"–12") | Pizzas | $12.99 – $15.99 | ~750 kcal (whole) | Wheat-sensitive diners | Availability varies; shared oven cross-contact applies |
Calzones, Strombolis & Rolls
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional Cheese Calzone | Calzones | $9.99 – $12.49 | ~950 kcal | Ricotta lovers | Pocket folded dough with ricotta, mozzarella, side marinara |
| Meat Calzone | Calzones | $11.49 – $13.99 | ~1,200 kcal | Hearty single meal | Stuffed with seasoned ricotta, mozzarella, sausage, pepperoni |
| Italian Meat Stromboli | Strombolis | $11.49 – $13.99 | ~1,250 kcal | Easy sharing | Rolled dough packed with ham, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella |
| Chicken Parmigiana Roll | Rolls | $9.49 – $11.99 | ~1,050 kcal | Portable chicken parm | Breaded cutlet strips, marinara, and mozzarella rolled up |
| Sausage, Pepper & Onion Roll | Rolls | $9.49 – $11.99 | ~980 kcal | Classic Italian street flavor | Sweet Italian sausage, bell peppers, onions in dough wrapper |
Hot & Cold Subs (8" – 12" Italian Heroes)
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Meatball Parmigiana Sub | Hot Subs | $9.49 – $11.99 | ~890 kcal | Classic comfort food | Beef/pork meatballs, house marinara, melted mozzarella |
| Chicken Parmigiana Sub | Hot Subs | $9.99 – $12.49 | ~940 kcal | Crispy sandwich fans | Breaded chicken cutlet toasted on hero roll with melted cheese |
| Philly Cheesesteak | Hot Subs | $10.49 – $12.99 | ~860 kcal | Hearty hot lunch | Thinly sliced steak, griddled onions, peppers, melted cheese |
| Sausage, Peppers & Onions Sub | Hot Subs | $9.49 – $11.49 | ~820 kcal | Savory hot grinder | Sliced sausage links, sweet peppers, griddled onions |
| Italian Cold Combo Hero | Cold Subs | $9.99 – $12.49 | ~780 kcal | Cold sub lovers | Ham, salami, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato, oil & vinegar |
Appetizers, Wings & Baked Pastas
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Garlic Knots (6 Pieces) | Appetizers | $3.99 – $4.99 | ~480 kcal | Affordable side | Tied dough baked with garlic oil, parmesan; side marinara |
| Garlic Knots (12 Pieces) | Appetizers | $6.49 – $7.99 | ~960 kcal | Table sharing | Double order with two side cups of marinara |
| Mozzarella Sticks (6 Pieces) | Appetizers | $6.99 – $8.49 | ~580 kcal | Kids & starters | Golden battered cheese sticks served with marinara |
| Bone-In Buffalo Wings (10 Pieces) | Wings | $12.99 – $15.99 | ~850–1,050 kcal | Game day app | Choice of Mild, Hot, BBQ, or Garlic Parm with dressing |
| Baked Ziti | Baked Pasta | $11.99 – $14.99 | ~920 kcal | Filling pasta dinner | Penne tossed with marinara and ricotta, baked under mozzarella |
| Meat Lasagna | Baked Pasta | $12.99 – $15.99 | ~1,080 kcal | Classic baked entree | Wide pasta sheets layered with ground beef, ricotta, and sauce |
Popular Menu Items
When checking a brother's pizza menu, newcomers will find several legendary staples that repeat across almost every location:
| Popular Item | Why People Order It | Price Note | Calorie Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16" Large Cheese Pizza | Benchmark NY-style slice with crisp base and foldable crust | $16.99 – $18.99 | ~270 kcal per slice (8 slices) |
| Sicilian Deep Dish Square | Thick, olive-oil-crisped crust with fluffy focaccia center | $20.99 – $24.99 | ~400 kcal per square (12 slices) |
| Italian Meat Stromboli | Rolled log of cured meats and cheese that slices into pinwheels | $11.49 – $13.99 | ~1,250 kcal (serves 1–2) |
| Chicken Parmigiana Hero | Toasted Italian roll stacked with cutlets, red sauce, and broiled cheese | $9.99 – $12.49 | ~940 kcal |
| Garlic Knots with Marinara | Soft dough knots soaked in garlic butter and grated cheese | $3.99 – $4.99 (6 pc) | ~80 kcal per knot |
- 16" Large Hand-Tossed Pizza: Baked directly on seasoned pizza stones, this pie features a light, airy outer cornicione and a rigid undercarriage that supports the sauce and cheese without falling apart.
- Sicilian Square Pie: A 16"x16" deep-dish creation proofed in oiled sheet pans. The bottom fries gently in the oven, producing a crunchy crust supporting thick marinara and molten mozzarella.
- Meat Stromboli: Unlike calzones, which feature ricotta cheese and a half-moon fold, Brother's strombolis roll ham, salami, pepperoni, and mozzarella like a jelly roll before baking to a golden sheen.
- Meatball or Chicken Parm Sub: Served on an authentic Italian hero roll, this sub holds up under rich, slow-simmered tomato sauce without getting soggy before the final bite.
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
These are LatestMenus editorial recommendations based on available menu research, value, popularity, customization potential, and practical ordering usefulness. They are not official restaurant rankings.
16" Large Cheese Pizza (Well-Done)
The true test of any NY slice shop. Requesting it "well-done" ensures a sturdy, caramelized bottom crust that prevents cheese-slide and center-flop.
2-Slice Lunch Special with Soda
A midday staple delivering two giant counter-reheated slices and a chilled canned soda for under ten dollars at almost every location.
16"x16" Sicilian Square Pie
Cuts into 12 dense, focaccia-thick squares that satisfy hungry kids and groups far better than a standard round thin-crust pie.
House Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken
Crisp iceberg and romaine loaded with tomatoes, cucumbers, and grilled chicken breast, skipping the heavy mozzarella and breadings.
Chicken Parmigiana Sub
Crispy cutlets, tangy marinara, and melted mozzarella broiled into a crunchy, toasted Italian hero roll.
Custom Cheese Calzone
Start with the creamy ricotta and mozzarella dough pocket, then add any pizza toppings (sausage, mushrooms, roasted garlic) inside.
Cheapest Items and Best Value Picks
Getting great value at Brother's Pizza comes down to knowing how pizza math works and avoiding delivery app surcharges.
| Value Pick | Why It Can Be Good Value | Watch Out For | Best Ordering Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2-Slice Lunch Special | Costs 25%–30% less than ordering slices and a drink separately | Available only on weekdays (typically 11 AM – 3 PM) | Ask for fresh garlic or oregano on top before reheating |
| 6-Piece Garlic Knots | Under $5.00 starter that easily feeds 2–3 people | High carb and garlic-oil density | Ask for an extra cup of marinara for dipping crusts |
| 18" XL Pie vs. Two 14" Mediums | An 18" pie offers 254 sq in of pizza for ~$21; two mediums cost ~$29 | Requires a wide counter and large fridge for leftovers | Split toppings half-and-half to please different tastes |
| Single Plain Cheese Slice | A fast, piping-hot meal for roughly $3.50 | Adding multiple gourmet toppings quickly inflates slice price | Dust with counter crushed red pepper and parmesan at no cost |
Calories and Nutrition Notes
Because Brother's Pizza storefronts are independently run and fall under the 20-location federal threshold, they are not legally required to publish lab-tested nutrition sheets. However, typical Italian-American preparation standards give reliable reference points:
| Menu Area | Nutrition Note | Best For | Source Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plain Cheese Slice (16" Pie) | ~260–300 kcal, 10–12g protein, 10–12g fat | Moderate, balanced treat | Medium (Pizzeria industry averages) |
| Specialty / Meat Lovers Slice | ~380–460 kcal, high saturated fat and sodium | High protein indulgence | Medium (Culinary standard estimates) |
| Whole Cheese Calzone | ~900–1,250 kcal, driven by dense whole-milk ricotta | Splitting into two separate meals | Medium (Portion size varies by store) |
| Garden / Antipasto Salad | ~250–550 kcal depending on dressing and cold cuts | Lower-carbohydrate dining | Medium (Ingredient based) |
- To Cut Calories: Order your pizza with "light cheese" or choose fresh vegetable toppings (mushrooms, green peppers, onions, spinach) rather than cured meats like pepperoni and sausage.
- Managing Sodium: Italian cured meats, pizza sauces, and aged cheeses contain elevated sodium levels. Pairing your meal with water rather than soda helps offset the sodium intake.
Allergen and Dietary Notes
Traditional deck-oven pizza shops present distinct challenges for diners with severe allergies:
| Dietary Need | What to Check | Important Note |
|---|---|---|
| Gluten / Wheat Allergy | Check if personal 10"–12" gluten-free crusts are stocked | Airborne flour and shared oven decks make cross-contact likely; not safe for celiac disease |
| Dairy / Lactose Intolerance | Request a "Tomato Pie" or vegetable pizza with NO cheese | Traditional Brother's dough and marinara are dairy-free; avoid garlic knots brushed with dairy butter |
| Egg Allergy | Skip breaded items (chicken/eggplant cutlets), meatballs, and cannoli | Standard pizza dough and pizza red sauce do not contain eggs |
| Vegetarian | Cheese pies, White Pizza, Eggplant Parm, and Veggie Deluxes | Confirm whether the house marinara uses meat bones or animal fat for seasoning |
| Vegan | Thin-crust dough topped with marinara and fresh veggies | Commercial vegan cheese is rarely stocked unless noted locally |
Special Menu Sections
Beyond the regular pizza lineup, most Brother's Pizza locations offer dedicated deals, sweets, and family trays.
Lunch Specials & Midday Deals
| Item or Section | What It Includes | Price/Calorie Note | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plain Slice Combo | 2 plain cheese slices + 1 can of soda | $6.99 – $8.49 | ~690 kcal | Quick budget lunch |
| 1-Topping Slice Combo | 2 pepperoni or sausage slices + 1 drink | $7.99 – $9.49 | ~810 kcal | Meat lovers on the run |
| Sub & Chips Combo | 8" hot or cold sub + small chips/fries + drink | $9.49 – $11.99 | ~950–1,150 kcal | Hearty midday meal |
Italian Desserts & Sweets
- Cannoli ($3.99 – $5.49): Crisp, bubbly fried pastry shells piped to order with sweet vanilla-sweetened ricotta cream and mini chocolate chips.
- Tiramisu ($4.99 – $6.49): Soft ladyfingers soaked in espresso liqueur, topped with mascarpone whip, and dusted with dark cocoa powder.
- Powdered Zeppoles ($4.99 – $6.49 per bag): Deep-fried pizza dough puffs tossed inside a paper bag with confectioners' sugar.
Catering & Party Trays
For office events or family gatherings, Brother's Pizza typically offers half-sheet pans (serving 8–10) and full-sheet pans (serving 15–20):
- Half Tray Baked Ziti ($45.00 – $60.00): Penne layered with marinara, ricotta, and mozzarella.
- Full Tray Chicken Parmigiana ($85.00 – $110.00): Breaded chicken cutlets baked in marinara.
- Large House Salad Pan ($30.00 – $40.00): Fresh greens with tomatoes, olives, and house Italian dressing.
(Looking for daytime dining instead of late-night pizza? If you are exploring regional breakfast spots, see our review of the Brothers Brunch House menu for morning plates and omelet prices.)
Best For: Who This Menu Guide Helps
- Diners Checking Local Price Ranges: Know in advance whether a 16" cheese pie costs $16 or $22 before stopping by the ATM or picking up the phone.
- Families and Parties: Calculate whether two 16" pies or one massive Sicilian square is the most budget-friendly choice.
- Office Workers Hunting Lunch Specials: Identify which shops feature the classic 2-slice-and-a-can deal under $9.00.
- Allergy-Conscious Customers: Get realistic transparency about airborne wheat flour, shared ovens, and cross-contact risks before ordering.
- Takeout Diners Avoiding App Surcharges: Learn how to avoid inflated third-party delivery prices.
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
Practical ordering guidance to ensure you get the freshest food and the lowest prices at your local Brother's Pizza.
- Order direct by phone or through direct storefront portals. Third-party delivery apps (DoorDash, Uber Eats) mark up Brother's menu prices by $2.00 to $4.00 per item on top of service fees. Calling the store directly saves money.
- Always ask for your pie "well-done." New York-style deck ovens can sometimes leave thin-crust centers slightly soft during busy rush hours. Ordering well-done ensures a sturdy, crispy slice.
- Verify calzone marinara serving styles. Authentic NY slice shops serve marinara in cold or warm plastic cups on the side. If you prefer your sauce inside or piping hot, let the counter staff know when ordering.
- Customize counter slices on the fly. If you walk in for a quick slice, you do not have to settle for plain cheese. Counter attendants can easily add pepperoni, sausage, or garlic onto a slice before sliding it into the reheating deck.
- Upgrade to the 16" or 18" pie for groups. Pizza geometry gives an 18" pie roughly 65% more edible area than a 14" pie for only a small price difference.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a large cheese pizza cost at Brother's Pizza?
A standard large 16-inch cheese pizza at Brother's Pizza ranges between $16.99 and $18.99 at most regional storefronts in 2026. Extra toppings generally cost between $2.00 and $2.75 each.
Why do Brother's Pizza menu prices vary by location?
Brother's Pizza is not a corporate-owned national chain. The name is shared by dozens of independent, family-owned regional pizzerias and small mini-chains across states like Texas, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey. Each shop sets its own prices based on local labor, flour, and cheese costs.
Does Brother's Pizza sell pizza by the slice?
Yes. Nearly every brick-and-mortar Brother's Pizza location operates a walk-up slice display case. A plain cheese slice costs between $3.00 and $3.75, while pepperoni or specialty slices cost between $3.75 and $4.50.
Are calories listed on the Brother's Pizza menu?
No. Because individual Brother's Pizza locations operate as independent small businesses with fewer than 20 stores, they are exempt from federal FDA calorie disclosure mandates. A standard slice of 16" cheese pizza averages roughly 260 to 300 calories.
Does Brother's Pizza offer a gluten-free crust?
Some Brother's Pizza locations offer personal 10-inch or 12-inch gluten-free crusts. However, because pizzerias toss wheat flour openly and use shared deck ovens, cross-contact risk is high. Diners with severe celiac disease should exercise caution.
What are the best value items at Brother's Pizza?
The best values are the 2-slice lunch special with a soda ($6.99 – $8.99), the 6-pack of garlic knots ($3.99 – $4.99), and the 18" extra-large pie, which offers a much lower cost per square inch than smaller personal pies.
What is the most popular sub at Brother's Pizza?
The Chicken Parmigiana Sub and the Meatball Parmigiana Sub ($9.49 – $12.49) are the most frequently ordered hot heroes across all locations.
Are Brother's Pizza delivery prices higher than in-store pickup?
Yes. Third-party platforms like DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub typically mark up menu items by 15% to 25% over counter prices, in addition to service fees and delivery driver tips.
Does Brother's Pizza offer weekday lunch specials?
Yes. Most Brother's Pizza counters run lunch specials Monday through Friday between 11:00 AM and 3:00 PM, featuring slice combos or small sub combos paired with a beverage for under $10.00.
Can I order online from Brother's Pizza?
Yes, but ordering methods depend on the specific location. Many independent stores use direct digital ordering platforms like Toast, Slice, or Clover, which charge lower fees than national delivery aggregators.
Conclusion
The brother's pizza menu delivers timeless New York-style comfort food, from foldable, crispy thin-crust cheese pies to heavy Sicilian squares and toasted chicken parm subs. Because Brother's Pizza operates through independent, family-run kitchens rather than a rigid corporate structure, recipes and prices reflect local neighborhood craftsmanship. To get the best experience and the lowest price, call your local shop directly, check for weekday lunch slice deals, and order your pie "well-done" for that quintessential New York crunch.
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can change by location, time, delivery platform, and restaurant updates. Always confirm the latest information with the official restaurant website, app, or your local restaurant before ordering. Information verified for 2026 where available.
