Big Fellas Menu with Prices, Calories and Popular Items
Looking for the Big Fellas menu before placing a dinner or game-day order? Big Fella’s Pizza operates primarily as a regional, independent pizzeria concept celebrated for heavy-topped pies, generous party-sized pizzas, saucy wings, and hearty Italian-American sides. Whether you are feeding a hungry family or checking options for late-night pickup, knowing what to expect on the menu helps you pick the right meal at the best price.
Because Big Fella’s operates as an independent or regional brand across select markets rather than a single unified corporate franchise, exact menu selections, crust dimensions, and pricing vary by location, ordering platform, and time. In this guide, LatestMenus breaks down typical Big Fellas menu prices, popular specialty pizzas, estimated calorie benchmarks, allergen considerations, and practical money-saving ordering tips.
Menu Snapshot: Quick Answer
A standard meal at Big Fella's typically features medium 12-inch pizzas ($12.99–$18.49), large 16-inch pies ($16.99–$24.99), calzones ($11.99–$13.99), and crispy buffalo wings ($8.99–$17.99). Calorie counts are not officially published by a central database, but standard slices range between 210 and 420 calories depending on topping density.
Official Source Verification
Official Source Verification
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can vary by location, delivery platform, and time. LatestMenus checks official restaurant sources where available and marks uncertain information clearly.
Latest Big Fellas Menu Prices
The following menu items and estimated pricing represent typical dine-in and takeout rates across independent regional Big Fella’s locations. If you enjoy comparing regional Italian-American pizza shops, you might also like browsing the Big Tony's Pizzeria menu for alternate crust styles and pricing tiers.
Note: Pricing and size availability vary by specific storefront. Confirm current rates with your local restaurant.
| Menu Item | Category | Price | Calories | Best For | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Classic Cheese Pizza | Traditional Pizzas | $12.99 – $18.49 | 210–290 kcal / slice | Kids & Purists | Herb tomato sauce blend with whole-milk aged mozzarella. |
| Pepperoni Pizza | Traditional Pizzas | $14.49 – $19.99 | 240–320 kcal / slice | Quick Dinner | Classic hand-tossed dough topped with sliced cured pepperoni. |
| The Big Fella Supreme | Specialty Pizzas | $17.99 – $24.99 | 290–380 kcal / slice | Crowd Sharing | Pepperoni, Italian sausage, beef, peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives. |
| Meat Lover’s Feast | Specialty Pizzas | $18.49 – $25.49 | 320–420 kcal / slice | Meat Eaters | Layered pepperoni, savory ham, Italian sausage, bacon, and ground beef. |
| BBQ Chicken Bacon | Specialty Pizzas | $17.49 – $23.99 | 270–350 kcal / slice | Tangy Flavor | Seasoned chicken breast, red onions, smoked bacon, BBQ drizzle. |
| White Garlic & Spinach | Specialty Pizzas | $16.99 – $22.99 | 250–320 kcal / slice | Vegetarians | Ricotta cheese base, roasted garlic oil, baby spinach, mozzarella. |
| Hawaiian Pizza | Traditional Pizzas | $15.49 – $20.99 | 230–300 kcal / slice | Sweet & Savory | Cured sliced ham and sweet pineapple over tomato sauce. |
| Veggie Delight | Traditional Pizzas | $15.99 – $21.49 | 210–280 kcal / slice | Lighter Dinner | Mushrooms, green peppers, red onions, black olives, diced tomatoes. |
| Traditional Calzone | Calzones & Strombolis | $11.99 – $13.99 | 850–1,100 kcal | Solo Comfort Meal | Stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of 2 pizza toppings. |
| Meatball Parmigiana Sub | Hot Subs | $9.49 – $12.99 | 710–950 kcal | Hearty Lunch | Toasted sub roll with Italian meatballs, marinara, and melted provolone. |
| Italian Cold Cut Sub | Cold Subs | $8.99 – $12.49 | 620–890 kcal | On-the-Go Meal | Ham, salami, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato, Italian dressing. |
| Baked Lasagna | Pastas & Entrees | $12.99 – $15.99 | 850–1,120 kcal | Classic Italian | Layered pasta sheets, ground beef ragu, bechamel, and melted cheese. |
| Bone-In Buffalo Wings (12 pc) | Wings & Sides | $16.49 – $17.99 | 960–1,080 kcal | Game Day | Crispy fried chicken wings tossed in mild, medium, or hot Buffalo sauce. |
| Boneless Chicken Bites (8 pc) | Wings & Sides | $7.99 – $8.99 | 420–490 kcal | Snacking | Breaded breast pieces with blue cheese or ranch dipping sauce. |
| Cheesy Garlic Breadsticks | Starters & Sides | $5.99 – $7.49 | 140 kcal / stick | Table Starter | House pizza dough brushed with garlic butter and topped with mozzarella. |
| Garlic Knots (6 pc) | Starters & Sides | $4.49 – $5.49 | 90 kcal / knot | Budget Add-On | Tossed in olive oil, fresh garlic, parmesan, and parsley; marinara included. |
| Nutella Dessert Pizza | Desserts | $6.99 – $8.99 | 180–240 kcal / slice | Sweet Tooth | Folded or flat crust smothered in warm chocolate hazelnut spread. |
Popular Menu Items
If you are visiting a Big Fella's location for the first time, these signature choices consistently rank among customer favorites:
| Popular Item | Why People Order It | Price Note | Calorie Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Big Fella Supreme | Generous balance of three meats and three fresh vegetables on a sturdy crust. | $17.99 – $24.99 | ~290–380 kcal / slice |
| Meat Lover’s Feast | Packed with five meats; ideal for high-protein appetites and sporting events. | $18.49 – $25.49 | ~320–420 kcal / slice |
| Cheesy Garlic Breadsticks | High cheese pull, budget-friendly, and perfect for dipping in warm marinara. | $5.99 – $7.49 | ~140 kcal / stick |
| Bone-In Buffalo Wings | Oven-crisped skin, tangy vinegar-cayenne sauce, and generous meat portions. | $16.49 – $17.99 (12 pc) | ~960–1,080 kcal total |
| Baked Lasagna | Classic homemade comfort with rich meat sauce and heavy melted mozzarella. | $12.99 – $15.99 | ~850–1,120 kcal |
Item Spotlight: The Big Fella Supreme Pizza
The brand's namesake specialty pie combines classic cured meats (pepperoni, Italian sausage, and seasoned ground beef) with earthy vegetables (green bell peppers, white onions, sliced button mushrooms, and black olives). It features a medium-thick, hand-tossed dough with a sturdy rim capable of supporting heavy toppings without sagging in the center.
Item Spotlight: Cheesy Garlic Breadsticks
Prepared using the same slow-fermented dough as the traditional pizzas, these breadsticks are brushed with garlic-infused butter, coated in dried oregano and grated parmesan, and topped with shredded mozzarella before baking. They serve as an affordable starter for group orders.
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
Editor Picks: Best Things to Order
These are LatestMenus editorial recommendations based on available menu research, value, popularity, customization potential, and practical ordering usefulness. They are not official restaurant rankings.
The Big Fella Supreme Pizza
This signature pie delivers the ideal ratio of seasoned meats and fresh vegetables, ensuring every bite is balanced rather than greasy.
Two-Large Pizza Combo Deal
Bundling two large one-topping pies with an order of cheesy garlic bread reliably drops the per-person dining cost by 20% to 25%.
Jumbo / Party Sheet Pizza
A single sheet or giant cut pizza yields 24 square-cut party slices, making it easier to manage kids and group events than multiple individual boxes.
White Garlic & Spinach Pizza
Swapping heavy red meat toppings for whole baby spinach and roasted garlic over a lighter ricotta layer provides a satisfying, less sodium-heavy alternative.
Meat Lover’s Feast
A perennial crowd favorite built with five meats and extra mozzarella, making it a reliable pick for game-day gatherings.
Traditional Calzone (Build Your Own)
Lets you select your favorite two pizza ingredients folded with seasoned ricotta and mozzarella, baked to order with marinara on the side.
Cheapest Items and Best Value Picks
Pizzerias frequently offer excellent price-per-calorie ratios if you understand how to navigate counter specials and bundle deals. If you appreciate retro American comfort menus with budget-friendly entrees, consider exploring Big Time Diner menu prices as well.
| Value Pick | Why It Can Be Good Value | Watch Out For | Best Ordering Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weekday Lunch Slice Special | Provides two large 1-topping slices plus a 20 oz fountain drink for around $7.99–$8.99. | Usually cut off strictly at 2:00 PM on weekdays. | Call ahead or walk in directly between 11:30 AM and 1:30 PM. |
| 6-Piece Garlic Knots | At $4.49–$5.49 with dipping marinara, it serves 2–3 people for minimal expense. | Very carb-heavy starter with little protein. | Add as a side to a smaller pizza to stretch portions. |
| Half-and-Half Large Pizza | Avoids purchasing two separate medium pies to satisfy split household tastes. | Stores usually charge based on the higher-priced specialty half. | Combine two specialties with similar base sauces (e.g., Supreme and Meat Lovers). |
| Direct Counter Carryout | Eliminates 15%–30% delivery app markup and platform service fees. | Requires driving to the location for pickup. | Phone your order directly into the local kitchen. |
Calories and Nutrition Notes
Because Big Fella’s operates primarily as an independent and regional entity rather than a 20+ unit national chain subject to FDA menu labeling mandates, centralized, laboratory-tested nutritional data is not officially published. However, general pizza industry benchmarks help provide practical dietary context:
| Menu Area | Nutrition Note | Best For | Source Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese Pizza (16" Slice) | Estimated 210–290 calories, 9–12g fat, and 28–34g carbs per slice. | Baseline reference | Low (Industry Estimate) |
| Meat Pizzas (Supreme / Meat Lovers) | Estimated 320–420 calories and 15–22g fat per slice due to cured pork and beef. | Hearty, high-protein meals | Low (Industry Estimate) |
| Thin Crust Vegetable Pizzas | Estimated 190–240 calories per slice with reduced sodium and saturated fat. | Calorie-conscious diners | Low (Industry Estimate) |
| Baked Pastas & Calzones | Range from 850 to 1,150 calories per full entree portion. | Portion splitting / Leftovers | Low (Industry Estimate) |
Practical Nutrition Tip: Requesting "light cheese" on any specialty pie removes an estimated 40 to 60 calories per slice without compromising the flavor of the tomato sauce and seasonings.
Allergen and Dietary Notes
Pizzerias operate in high-flour, shared-oven environments. If you have severe celiac disease or life-threatening food allergies, verify kitchen handling procedures with the on-duty manager before ordering.
| Dietary Need | What to Check | Important Note |
|---|---|---|
| Gluten / Wheat Allergy | Check for 10" or 12" gluten-free crust availability. | Airborne flour and shared pizza peel surfaces present substantial cross-contact risk. |
| Dairy / Lactose Sensitivity | Ask if vegan cheese is stocked, or order a cheese-free tomato pie. | Garlic bread spreads, white sauces, and ricotta fillings all contain cow's milk. |
| Vegetarian Options | Order Classic Cheese, White Garlic & Spinach, or Veggie Delight. | Confirm whether pasta sauces use vegetable oil or animal-derived broth bases. |
| Peanuts & Tree Nuts | Inspect dessert pizzas and specialty pesto sauces. | Nutella dessert pizzas contain hazelnuts and introduce nut allergens to kitchen prep lines. |
Special Menu Sections
Crust Options & Specialty Sizes
- Hand-Tossed (Standard): Medium thickness with an airy, chewy crust ring and solid bottom firmness.
- Thin Crust: Available upon request at most locations; rolled thinner for an even, cracker-style bake.
- Jumbo Party Sheet: Ideal for school events, youth sports, and family reunions; cut into 24 party squares.
Wings & Hot Appetizers
Wing orders come either bone-in (unbreaded, fried crisp) or boneless (breaded white breast meat). Available sauces generally span:
- Mild, Medium, and Hot Buffalo
- Honey BBQ
- Garlic Parmesan
- Sweet Chili
Pastas, Subs & Desserts
Those looking beyond pizza can find Italian baked staples (Lasagna, Baked Ziti, Penne Bolognese) served in foil pans with garlic toast. Hot subs (Meatball Parm, Sausage & Peppers) and cold deli hoagies offer convenient lunch options. For a sweet finish, dessert calzones or Nutella flatbreads dusted with powdered sugar are common regional specialties.
Best For: Who This Menu Guide Helps
This Big Fellas menu breakdown helps:
- Diners checking prices before visiting: Get realistic estimates for pies, sides, and pasta platters.
- Families and party planners: Determine whether a sheet pizza or two-pie bundle offers the lowest cost per person.
- Delivery app customers: Spot platform markups and decide whether direct pickup saves meaningful money.
- Health-conscious eaters: Review estimated calorie benchmarks and identify lighter crust and topping options.
- Diners with dietary restrictions: Understand wheat and dairy allergen risks before ordering from a shared kitchen.
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
Ordering Tips From LatestMenus
Use these practical, field-tested recommendations to get the freshest food and the best value on your next Big Fella's pizza order.
- Order direct to bypass third-party app markups. Services like DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub frequently mark up local pizza items by 15% to 30%, in addition to delivery and platform fees. Calling the store directly keeps menu prices at baseline.
- Request "well-done" on multi-topping pies. Heavy pizzas like the Meat Lover’s Feast or Supreme release moisture during baking. Requesting a well-done bake ensures the bottom crust stays firm and crisp under the topping load.
- Leverage half-and-half specialty sizing. If your household cannot agree on toppings, order a large or extra-large pizza split half-and-half rather than two medium pies. Independent pizzerias generally bill only for the higher-priced half.
- Inquire about party sheet pans for large gatherings. If you are feeding six or more guests, check whether your store bakes sheet or 24-inch pies. Sheet pizzas provide significantly more square inches of food per dollar than round pizzas.
- Confirm weekday lunch special hours. Lunch slice combos (usually 2 slices and a drink) offer substantial savings, but most independent shops end counter service promptly at 2:00 PM.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Big Fellas have an official menu with prices?
Because Big Fella’s operates primarily as an independent and regional brand, official prices are published through local storefront paper menus, in-store counter displays, and regional online POS checkout portals rather than a single corporate website.
How much does a large pizza cost at Big Fellas?
A standard large 16-inch cheese pizza typically costs between $14.49 and $18.49. Specialty pies with multiple meats and vegetables (like the Big Fella Supreme) generally range from $21.99 to $25.49 depending on regional ingredient costs.
What are the standard pizza sizes at Big Fellas?
Most locations offer Small (10", 6 slices), Medium (12", 8 slices), Large (16", 8–10 slices), and Extra-Large or Party Sheet (18"+, 12 triangular slices or 24 square-cut pieces).
Where can I find official Big Fellas calorie counts?
Official laboratory nutrition figures are not published because independent and regional pizza establishments are generally exempt from mandatory federal chain restaurant labeling regulations. Industry benchmarks estimate 210–290 calories for a plain cheese slice and 320–420 calories for a meat-heavy specialty slice.
Does Big Fellas have an allergen menu?
No centralized, formal allergen menu exists across all storefronts. Diners with severe wheat, dairy, soy, or nut allergies should speak directly with the kitchen supervisor to ask about cross-contact risks before ordering.
Does Big Fellas offer gluten-free crust?
Select locations provide a 10-inch or 12-inch gluten-free crust for a modest upcharge (usually $3.00 to $4.00). However, kitchens handle raw wheat flour throughout the day, meaning airborne cross-contact can occur.
What are the most popular items on the Big Fellas menu?
Customer favorites include The Big Fella Supreme Pizza, Meat Lover’s Feast, Cheesy Garlic Breadsticks, Bone-In Buffalo Wings, and traditional baked calzones. If you also enjoy checking out casual spots known for bold names and street food, explore the 2 Crazy Fellas menu for another interesting regional perspective.
Are Big Fellas menu prices cheaper for pickup than delivery?
Yes. Calling the restaurant for carryout or using their direct online POS checkout avoids the 15% to 30% item markup and service fees commonly added by third-party delivery apps.
Does Big Fellas offer lunch specials?
Yes. Most locations run a weekday lunch special from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM featuring two pizza slices and a fountain beverage or a small hot sub combo priced around $7.99 to $9.49.
Can I customize half-and-half pizzas at Big Fellas?
Yes. Most independent pizzerias allow you to split toppings or specialty styles on medium, large, and extra-large pies, typically billing at the price of the higher-tier half.
Conclusion
The Big Fellas menu focuses on classic comfort food, generous specialty pies, saucy buffalo wings, and oven-baked pastas tailored for family gatherings and sports nights. Because locations operate as independent or regional pizzerias, menu offerings, promotions, and prices vary between neighborhoods and delivery platforms.
For the most accurate pricing and best value, contact your nearest storefront directly to confirm local slice specials, ask about party sheet dimensions, and skip third-party app delivery markups.
Menus, prices, calories, and availability can change by location, time, delivery platform, and restaurant updates. Always confirm the latest information with the official restaurant website, app, or your local restaurant before ordering. Information verified for 2026 where available.
